The information on this site is not intended or implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Content within the patient forum is user-generated and has not been reviewed by medical professionals. Other sections of the Melanoma Research Foundation website include information that has been reviewed by medical professionals as appropriate. All medical decisions should be made in consultation with your doctor or other qualified medical professional.

Long term NED

Forums General Melanoma Community Long term NED

  • Post
    Jewel
    Participant

    My husband has been fortunate enough to be NED 2 1/2 years after his last surgery. My question

    to all of you who are currently NED is how many are there out there that have achieved long term NED

    with JUST surgery alone. Stage3/4..my husband is 3c.

    Thank you

    Jewel

Viewing 14 reply threads
  • Replies
      Jahendry12
      Participant

      Hi Jewel – My husband was diagnosed in April 2011 and his only form of treatment has been surgery.  He was NED from May 2011 – Feb 2013.  A scan found a met on his left lung, they went in, took it out and so far so good.  We have a CT next month and if all clear, he will be 1 year NED.

      Hope that helps.  If you want to read his profile, see Robert H under Patient Stories.

      Hope your husband remains NED for many many years to come ๐Ÿ™‚

      Julie

      Jahendry12
      Participant

      Hi Jewel – My husband was diagnosed in April 2011 and his only form of treatment has been surgery.  He was NED from May 2011 – Feb 2013.  A scan found a met on his left lung, they went in, took it out and so far so good.  We have a CT next month and if all clear, he will be 1 year NED.

      Hope that helps.  If you want to read his profile, see Robert H under Patient Stories.

      Hope your husband remains NED for many many years to come ๐Ÿ™‚

      Julie

      Jahendry12
      Participant

      Hi Jewel – My husband was diagnosed in April 2011 and his only form of treatment has been surgery.  He was NED from May 2011 – Feb 2013.  A scan found a met on his left lung, they went in, took it out and so far so good.  We have a CT next month and if all clear, he will be 1 year NED.

      Hope that helps.  If you want to read his profile, see Robert H under Patient Stories.

      Hope your husband remains NED for many many years to come ๐Ÿ™‚

      Julie

      dodgedh2
      Participant

      I was treated by surgery and gamma radiation during surgery. They removed the tumor from my sacrum and treated the area where the tumor was removed with Gamma radiation before closing me up. I have been NED for over 5-1/2 years now.

      dodgedh2
      Participant

      I was treated by surgery and gamma radiation during surgery. They removed the tumor from my sacrum and treated the area where the tumor was removed with Gamma radiation before closing me up. I have been NED for over 5-1/2 years now.

      dodgedh2
      Participant

      I was treated by surgery and gamma radiation during surgery. They removed the tumor from my sacrum and treated the area where the tumor was removed with Gamma radiation before closing me up. I have been NED for over 5-1/2 years now.

      Randy437
      Participant

      Beginning in December, 2007 I have had single mets to both lungs, brain and small intestine surgically removed and have been NED since January, 2010.  I was in a vaccine clinical trial in 2009 and have no way of knowing if it has a bearing on my NED status.  The met to the small intestine was discovered after I completed the trial – but it never showed up on any of the CT scans before and during the trail.  A falling iron count led to a PET scan that pinpointed the small met.  So it may have been there before I started the trial as I was told small mets in the small intestine can "hide" from CT scans.

      Randy437
      Participant

      Beginning in December, 2007 I have had single mets to both lungs, brain and small intestine surgically removed and have been NED since January, 2010.  I was in a vaccine clinical trial in 2009 and have no way of knowing if it has a bearing on my NED status.  The met to the small intestine was discovered after I completed the trial – but it never showed up on any of the CT scans before and during the trail.  A falling iron count led to a PET scan that pinpointed the small met.  So it may have been there before I started the trial as I was told small mets in the small intestine can "hide" from CT scans.

      Randy437
      Participant

      Beginning in December, 2007 I have had single mets to both lungs, brain and small intestine surgically removed and have been NED since January, 2010.  I was in a vaccine clinical trial in 2009 and have no way of knowing if it has a bearing on my NED status.  The met to the small intestine was discovered after I completed the trial – but it never showed up on any of the CT scans before and during the trail.  A falling iron count led to a PET scan that pinpointed the small met.  So it may have been there before I started the trial as I was told small mets in the small intestine can "hide" from CT scans.

      Bubbles
      Participant

      Small lesion on back and postive sentinel node…both removed with complete axillary lymphadenectomy in 2003.  NED for 4  years...then,2007 – small lesion to left forearm, no positive nodes, but did complete lymphadenectomy anyway .  NED for 3 years…then, 2010 – lesion in lung, when bronch positive for melanoma, MRI found lesion in brain…SRS to brain, surgery to lung.  NED for 6 months….then, still 2010 – tonsil surgically removed, positive for melanoma.  Today….NED 3 years 3 months…but did complete NED, 2 1/2 year trial of Nivolumab in June 2013.  No systemic treatments before Nivo.  So….some people do very well with surgical 'cherry picking'.  Just keep up a routine of scans so nothing escapes your notice!!!  Wishing you all my best.  Celeste

      Bubbles
      Participant

      Small lesion on back and postive sentinel node…both removed with complete axillary lymphadenectomy in 2003.  NED for 4  years...then,2007 – small lesion to left forearm, no positive nodes, but did complete lymphadenectomy anyway .  NED for 3 years…then, 2010 – lesion in lung, when bronch positive for melanoma, MRI found lesion in brain…SRS to brain, surgery to lung.  NED for 6 months….then, still 2010 – tonsil surgically removed, positive for melanoma.  Today….NED 3 years 3 months…but did complete NED, 2 1/2 year trial of Nivolumab in June 2013.  No systemic treatments before Nivo.  So….some people do very well with surgical 'cherry picking'.  Just keep up a routine of scans so nothing escapes your notice!!!  Wishing you all my best.  Celeste

      Bubbles
      Participant

      Small lesion on back and postive sentinel node…both removed with complete axillary lymphadenectomy in 2003.  NED for 4  years...then,2007 – small lesion to left forearm, no positive nodes, but did complete lymphadenectomy anyway .  NED for 3 years…then, 2010 – lesion in lung, when bronch positive for melanoma, MRI found lesion in brain…SRS to brain, surgery to lung.  NED for 6 months….then, still 2010 – tonsil surgically removed, positive for melanoma.  Today….NED 3 years 3 months…but did complete NED, 2 1/2 year trial of Nivolumab in June 2013.  No systemic treatments before Nivo.  So….some people do very well with surgical 'cherry picking'.  Just keep up a routine of scans so nothing escapes your notice!!!  Wishing you all my best.  Celeste

      GiniaJR1949
      Participant

      Hi Jewel: I have been NED for 10.5 years, with only one month of hi-dose Interferon (had to quit after two weeks on low-dose) and 5 positive axillary nodes under left arm. Original site was mole on my upper left back. I have had some scares but non proved to be the melanoma coming back. Keep the faith. It DOES happen. I remain vigilant and have regular scans and bloodwork.

      GiniaJR1949
      Participant

      Hi Jewel: I have been NED for 10.5 years, with only one month of hi-dose Interferon (had to quit after two weeks on low-dose) and 5 positive axillary nodes under left arm. Original site was mole on my upper left back. I have had some scares but non proved to be the melanoma coming back. Keep the faith. It DOES happen. I remain vigilant and have regular scans and bloodwork.

      GiniaJR1949
      Participant

      Hi Jewel: I have been NED for 10.5 years, with only one month of hi-dose Interferon (had to quit after two weeks on low-dose) and 5 positive axillary nodes under left arm. Original site was mole on my upper left back. I have had some scares but non proved to be the melanoma coming back. Keep the faith. It DOES happen. I remain vigilant and have regular scans and bloodwork.

Viewing 14 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
About the MRF Patient Forum

The MRF Patient Forum is the oldest and largest online community of people affected by melanoma. It is designed to provide peer support and information to caregivers, patients, family and friends. There is no better place to discuss different parts of your journey with this cancer and find the friends and support resources to make that journey more bearable.

The information on the forum is open and accessible to everyone. To add a new topic or to post a reply, you must be a registered user. Please note that you will be able to post both topics and replies anonymously even though you are logged in. All posts must abide byย MRF posting policies.

Popular Topics