The information on this site is not intended or implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Content within the patient forum is user-generated and has not been reviewed by medical professionals. Other sections of the Melanoma Research Foundation website include information that has been reviewed by medical professionals as appropriate. All medical decisions should be made in consultation with your doctor or other qualified medical professional.

Help please…

Forums General Melanoma Community Help please…

  • Post
    Joe.Pro
    Participant

      So…today my life changed.  My biopsy came back positive for malignant melanoma and I'm undoubtedly quite scared based on a few factors.

      Here are my details:

      34 year old white male diagnosed today with AML.  4.26mm Breslow and IV Clark scale according to the pathology report I received from my podiatrist as the lesion is located on the bottom of my foot.  I know this lesion has been present for 18 months but I foolishly ignored it.  

      I am preparing for my visit next week to Dana Farber Institute in Boston and am curious what questions I should be asking…are there better places to look for treatment based on results?

      I'm obviously brand new to this disease and it's very scary as I'm sure all of you know.  

      Please help…

      joe

       

       

    Viewing 20 reply threads
    • Replies
        Eileensulliv
        Participant

          Hi Joe, first I'd like to say I am sorry about your diagnosis. I know just how scary it is, as I was just diagnosed in January. I know some others on this board have a great amount of great advice, and I'm hopeful a few will chime in. My first bit of advice is to make sure you see an oncologist that specializes in melanoma. There are several newish treatment options, with very positive responses, and someone who specializes in melanoma will better guide you to options and decisions. 

          My second bit of advice is please do not get wrapped up in the statistics of melanoma. Since there have been many advances in just the last few years, the statistics are old and do not accurately reflect what melanoma treatment responses are like today. The statistics, quite frankly, scared the crap outta me!

          Next, I'd say be your own advocate. Research your options. Research your doctors, facilities, etc. Don't be afraid to ask questions, get second opinions, and even give your own opinions. Ask this board for recommendations on doctors and facilities. I personally don't know about the doctors in your area, but someone here may be able to give you advice on that one.

          Finally, I know it's hard, but keep your chin up! I have my bad days, or even just moments, and that's fine. But I keep my eyes on the prize, and then I smile! Reach out anytime you want. I know this board has been very helpful to me, and I hope it will be as helpful for you, as well!

          Eileensulliv
          Participant

            Hi Joe, first I'd like to say I am sorry about your diagnosis. I know just how scary it is, as I was just diagnosed in January. I know some others on this board have a great amount of great advice, and I'm hopeful a few will chime in. My first bit of advice is to make sure you see an oncologist that specializes in melanoma. There are several newish treatment options, with very positive responses, and someone who specializes in melanoma will better guide you to options and decisions. 

            My second bit of advice is please do not get wrapped up in the statistics of melanoma. Since there have been many advances in just the last few years, the statistics are old and do not accurately reflect what melanoma treatment responses are like today. The statistics, quite frankly, scared the crap outta me!

            Next, I'd say be your own advocate. Research your options. Research your doctors, facilities, etc. Don't be afraid to ask questions, get second opinions, and even give your own opinions. Ask this board for recommendations on doctors and facilities. I personally don't know about the doctors in your area, but someone here may be able to give you advice on that one.

            Finally, I know it's hard, but keep your chin up! I have my bad days, or even just moments, and that's fine. But I keep my eyes on the prize, and then I smile! Reach out anytime you want. I know this board has been very helpful to me, and I hope it will be as helpful for you, as well!

            Eileensulliv
            Participant

              Hi Joe, first I'd like to say I am sorry about your diagnosis. I know just how scary it is, as I was just diagnosed in January. I know some others on this board have a great amount of great advice, and I'm hopeful a few will chime in. My first bit of advice is to make sure you see an oncologist that specializes in melanoma. There are several newish treatment options, with very positive responses, and someone who specializes in melanoma will better guide you to options and decisions. 

              My second bit of advice is please do not get wrapped up in the statistics of melanoma. Since there have been many advances in just the last few years, the statistics are old and do not accurately reflect what melanoma treatment responses are like today. The statistics, quite frankly, scared the crap outta me!

              Next, I'd say be your own advocate. Research your options. Research your doctors, facilities, etc. Don't be afraid to ask questions, get second opinions, and even give your own opinions. Ask this board for recommendations on doctors and facilities. I personally don't know about the doctors in your area, but someone here may be able to give you advice on that one.

              Finally, I know it's hard, but keep your chin up! I have my bad days, or even just moments, and that's fine. But I keep my eyes on the prize, and then I smile! Reach out anytime you want. I know this board has been very helpful to me, and I hope it will be as helpful for you, as well!

              arthurjedi007
              Participant

                I'm sorry I'm not very familiar with stage 1 or 2. I assume you are stage 1. I have read about some folks on here that go to Dana farber and it seems like a good place. Just make sure your doc is a melanoma specialist. They have them there. I imagine they might want to do a scan to see if you have it elsewhere but I'm not sure because I'm not familiar with Breslow stuff. Could be they will do a type of surgery to remove it with clear margins. So basically making sure this is the only spot and if so getting it out so you become NED (no evidence of disease). since you've had it for 18 months I would think they would want to be cautious and do a scan but I dunno.

                For a little encouragement hopefully I've been stage 4 since June 21 of 2013. I'm still fighting it with around 30 tumors. Others have done way better too.

                Artie

                arthurjedi007
                Participant

                  I'm sorry I'm not very familiar with stage 1 or 2. I assume you are stage 1. I have read about some folks on here that go to Dana farber and it seems like a good place. Just make sure your doc is a melanoma specialist. They have them there. I imagine they might want to do a scan to see if you have it elsewhere but I'm not sure because I'm not familiar with Breslow stuff. Could be they will do a type of surgery to remove it with clear margins. So basically making sure this is the only spot and if so getting it out so you become NED (no evidence of disease). since you've had it for 18 months I would think they would want to be cautious and do a scan but I dunno.

                  For a little encouragement hopefully I've been stage 4 since June 21 of 2013. I'm still fighting it with around 30 tumors. Others have done way better too.

                  Artie

                  arthurjedi007
                  Participant

                    I'm sorry I'm not very familiar with stage 1 or 2. I assume you are stage 1. I have read about some folks on here that go to Dana farber and it seems like a good place. Just make sure your doc is a melanoma specialist. They have them there. I imagine they might want to do a scan to see if you have it elsewhere but I'm not sure because I'm not familiar with Breslow stuff. Could be they will do a type of surgery to remove it with clear margins. So basically making sure this is the only spot and if so getting it out so you become NED (no evidence of disease). since you've had it for 18 months I would think they would want to be cautious and do a scan but I dunno.

                    For a little encouragement hopefully I've been stage 4 since June 21 of 2013. I'm still fighting it with around 30 tumors. Others have done way better too.

                    Artie

                    SABKLYN
                    Participant

                      Hi Joe,

                      the depth of your tumor puts you likely at 2b or 2c depending on whether or not there's ulceration.  From here you will probably be scheduled for a sentinel node biopsy to check your lymph nodes to see if any cells have moved to the nodes.  Once you get the final diagnosis,  you will discuss your care plan.

                      Dana Farber is a great facility.  You're in great hands!!

                       

                       I think there's a section here on MRF with questions you may want to ask…

                      Most importantly, take a breath.  This will play out over a long period of time.  There are great resources available here.  Hang in there Joe!

                      SABKLYN
                      Participant

                        Hi Joe,

                        the depth of your tumor puts you likely at 2b or 2c depending on whether or not there's ulceration.  From here you will probably be scheduled for a sentinel node biopsy to check your lymph nodes to see if any cells have moved to the nodes.  Once you get the final diagnosis,  you will discuss your care plan.

                        Dana Farber is a great facility.  You're in great hands!!

                         

                         I think there's a section here on MRF with questions you may want to ask…

                        Most importantly, take a breath.  This will play out over a long period of time.  There are great resources available here.  Hang in there Joe!

                        SABKLYN
                        Participant

                          Hi Joe,

                          the depth of your tumor puts you likely at 2b or 2c depending on whether or not there's ulceration.  From here you will probably be scheduled for a sentinel node biopsy to check your lymph nodes to see if any cells have moved to the nodes.  Once you get the final diagnosis,  you will discuss your care plan.

                          Dana Farber is a great facility.  You're in great hands!!

                           

                           I think there's a section here on MRF with questions you may want to ask…

                          Most importantly, take a breath.  This will play out over a long period of time.  There are great resources available here.  Hang in there Joe!

                          Rocco
                          Participant

                            Hi Joe –

                            So sorry to hear that you've been diagnosed.  It is scary and we've all been there.  You've landed on the right site to post questions, ask for advice, etc.  As for Dana Farber (DFCI), it is exceptional.  Their melanoma team led by Dr. Stephen Hodi is on the top of their game, up to date on cutting edge treatments and trials.  The nursing staff and all who work there are compassionate and caring professionals in the war against cancer.  I'm obviously partial to DFCI as I've been going there since my Stage IV diagnosis in 2005.   I've been cancer free (or NED – no evidence of disease in melanoma speak) since 2009. 

                            The others who replied to your post gave sage advice.  Ask your medical team detailed questions, advocate on your own behalf, continue to post questions here to gain patient to patient knowledge. 

                            Hang in there!

                            – Rocco, Stage IV since 2005, Ipilimumab responder and NED since 2009

                            Rocco
                            Participant

                              Hi Joe –

                              So sorry to hear that you've been diagnosed.  It is scary and we've all been there.  You've landed on the right site to post questions, ask for advice, etc.  As for Dana Farber (DFCI), it is exceptional.  Their melanoma team led by Dr. Stephen Hodi is on the top of their game, up to date on cutting edge treatments and trials.  The nursing staff and all who work there are compassionate and caring professionals in the war against cancer.  I'm obviously partial to DFCI as I've been going there since my Stage IV diagnosis in 2005.   I've been cancer free (or NED – no evidence of disease in melanoma speak) since 2009. 

                              The others who replied to your post gave sage advice.  Ask your medical team detailed questions, advocate on your own behalf, continue to post questions here to gain patient to patient knowledge. 

                              Hang in there!

                              – Rocco, Stage IV since 2005, Ipilimumab responder and NED since 2009

                                Joe.Pro
                                Participant

                                  Thank you so much Rocco, great to hear your feedback and I am very happy for you having NED for so long.  God is good as I trust He is in control.  

                                  Joe.Pro
                                  Participant

                                    Thank you so much Rocco, great to hear your feedback and I am very happy for you having NED for so long.  God is good as I trust He is in control.  

                                    Joe.Pro
                                    Participant

                                      Thank you so much Rocco, great to hear your feedback and I am very happy for you having NED for so long.  God is good as I trust He is in control.  

                                    Rocco
                                    Participant

                                      Hi Joe –

                                      So sorry to hear that you've been diagnosed.  It is scary and we've all been there.  You've landed on the right site to post questions, ask for advice, etc.  As for Dana Farber (DFCI), it is exceptional.  Their melanoma team led by Dr. Stephen Hodi is on the top of their game, up to date on cutting edge treatments and trials.  The nursing staff and all who work there are compassionate and caring professionals in the war against cancer.  I'm obviously partial to DFCI as I've been going there since my Stage IV diagnosis in 2005.   I've been cancer free (or NED – no evidence of disease in melanoma speak) since 2009. 

                                      The others who replied to your post gave sage advice.  Ask your medical team detailed questions, advocate on your own behalf, continue to post questions here to gain patient to patient knowledge. 

                                      Hang in there!

                                      – Rocco, Stage IV since 2005, Ipilimumab responder and NED since 2009

                                      Joe.Pro
                                      Participant

                                        Thank you all so much for the encouragement and words of wisdom.  I am anxious to meet my Oncology team at Dana Farber and get my treatment and recovery underway.  

                                        Does anyone have experience at Dana Farber in Boston?  

                                        It looks like Sloan/Kettering in NYC also has a great Mel department.

                                        Joe

                                        Joe.Pro
                                        Participant

                                          Thank you all so much for the encouragement and words of wisdom.  I am anxious to meet my Oncology team at Dana Farber and get my treatment and recovery underway.  

                                          Does anyone have experience at Dana Farber in Boston?  

                                          It looks like Sloan/Kettering in NYC also has a great Mel department.

                                          Joe

                                            SABKLYN
                                            Participant

                                              I'm being treated at Sloan Kettering Joe and they are terrific.  However, so is Dana Farber.  If you live in New England and at some point want a second opinion, you'd have that close proximity to Sloan Kettering.

                                              SABKLYN
                                              Participant

                                                I'm being treated at Sloan Kettering Joe and they are terrific.  However, so is Dana Farber.  If you live in New England and at some point want a second opinion, you'd have that close proximity to Sloan Kettering.

                                                SABKLYN
                                                Participant

                                                  I'm being treated at Sloan Kettering Joe and they are terrific.  However, so is Dana Farber.  If you live in New England and at some point want a second opinion, you'd have that close proximity to Sloan Kettering.

                                                  sweetaugust
                                                  Participant

                                                    I have also been a patient of Dr. Hodi's at Dana Farber in Boston since April 2000.  I couldn't be happier with Dr. Hodi or his team or Dana Farber's kindness to patients.  You can click on my name and view all my melanoma story if you like.  My first and deepest melanoma was 2mm deep in my upper right arm back in 2000. 

                                                    Best of luck to you, Laurie

                                                    sweetaugust
                                                    Participant

                                                      I have also been a patient of Dr. Hodi's at Dana Farber in Boston since April 2000.  I couldn't be happier with Dr. Hodi or his team or Dana Farber's kindness to patients.  You can click on my name and view all my melanoma story if you like.  My first and deepest melanoma was 2mm deep in my upper right arm back in 2000. 

                                                      Best of luck to you, Laurie

                                                      sweetaugust
                                                      Participant

                                                        I have also been a patient of Dr. Hodi's at Dana Farber in Boston since April 2000.  I couldn't be happier with Dr. Hodi or his team or Dana Farber's kindness to patients.  You can click on my name and view all my melanoma story if you like.  My first and deepest melanoma was 2mm deep in my upper right arm back in 2000. 

                                                        Best of luck to you, Laurie

                                                      Joe.Pro
                                                      Participant

                                                        Thank you all so much for the encouragement and words of wisdom.  I am anxious to meet my Oncology team at Dana Farber and get my treatment and recovery underway.  

                                                        Does anyone have experience at Dana Farber in Boston?  

                                                        It looks like Sloan/Kettering in NYC also has a great Mel department.

                                                        Joe

                                                        Jubes
                                                        Participant

                                                          Hi joe. So sorry to hear of your diagnosis. On the positive side. Finding it now when there are such effective treatments and trials is lucky! I took a friend to my first meeting with my (specialist melanoma) oncologist and not only did it help as she knew the layout of the hospital and practical things but she also recorded the meeting on her phone. That helps as you forget everything that is said. Good luck and try not to be afraid. It is a long path.

                                                          anne-Louise

                                                          Jubes
                                                          Participant

                                                            Hi joe. So sorry to hear of your diagnosis. On the positive side. Finding it now when there are such effective treatments and trials is lucky! I took a friend to my first meeting with my (specialist melanoma) oncologist and not only did it help as she knew the layout of the hospital and practical things but she also recorded the meeting on her phone. That helps as you forget everything that is said. Good luck and try not to be afraid. It is a long path.

                                                            anne-Louise

                                                            Jubes
                                                            Participant

                                                              Hi joe. So sorry to hear of your diagnosis. On the positive side. Finding it now when there are such effective treatments and trials is lucky! I took a friend to my first meeting with my (specialist melanoma) oncologist and not only did it help as she knew the layout of the hospital and practical things but she also recorded the meeting on her phone. That helps as you forget everything that is said. Good luck and try not to be afraid. It is a long path.

                                                              anne-Louise

                                                              Bubbles
                                                              Participant

                                                                Sorry for your diagnosis, but sounds like you are in good hands with your medical team and certainly will get amazing advice and support here. Hang in there. It will not always be fun, but you can handle this. Many of us on mpip are a testament to that! I wish you my best. Celeste

                                                                Bubbles
                                                                Participant

                                                                  Sorry for your diagnosis, but sounds like you are in good hands with your medical team and certainly will get amazing advice and support here. Hang in there. It will not always be fun, but you can handle this. Many of us on mpip are a testament to that! I wish you my best. Celeste

                                                                  Bubbles
                                                                  Participant

                                                                    Sorry for your diagnosis, but sounds like you are in good hands with your medical team and certainly will get amazing advice and support here. Hang in there. It will not always be fun, but you can handle this. Many of us on mpip are a testament to that! I wish you my best. Celeste

                                                                Viewing 20 reply threads
                                                                • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
                                                                About the MRF Patient Forum

                                                                The MRF Patient Forum is the oldest and largest online community of people affected by melanoma. It is designed to provide peer support and information to caregivers, patients, family and friends. There is no better place to discuss different parts of your journey with this cancer and find the friends and support resources to make that journey more bearable.

                                                                The information on the forum is open and accessible to everyone. To add a new topic or to post a reply, you must be a registered user. Please note that you will be able to post both topics and replies anonymously even though you are logged in. All posts must abide by MRF posting policies.

                                                                Popular Topics