The information on this site is not intended or implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Content within the patient forum is user-generated and has not been reviewed by medical professionals. Other sections of the Melanoma Research Foundation website include information that has been reviewed by medical professionals as appropriate. All medical decisions should be made in consultation with your doctor or other qualified medical professional.

Which Melanoma Cancer Center shall we turn to?

Forums General Melanoma Community Which Melanoma Cancer Center shall we turn to?

  • Post
    fenny
    Participant

      Anyone can tell me which cancer center in the States is the best for musocal vaginal melanoma?  Is Moffitt Cancer Center in Tampa, Florida is good choice? I tried to contact Dr. Hodi at Dana Farber Cancer Institute in Boston, but no response.  My sister had a major operation in Beijing Cancer Center on Nov 16.

      Anyone can tell me which cancer center in the States is the best for musocal vaginal melanoma?  Is Moffitt Cancer Center in Tampa, Florida is good choice? I tried to contact Dr. Hodi at Dana Farber Cancer Institute in Boston, but no response.  My sister had a major operation in Beijing Cancer Center on Nov 16. She had her uterus, vagina and part of her vulva removed and she's now recovering from the surgery while waiting for the new chemo thrapy. I really wanna take my sister to the best melanoma hospital in the USA and we cannot affort to waste money, so pls offer your valuable info about the best one in the States. Thx.  

    Viewing 23 reply threads
    • Replies
        jackiewin
        Participant

          The following is a list of the top 5 cancer hospitals in the US. 

          1.  MD Anderson, Houston, Texas

          2. Sloan Kettering, New York City

          3. John Hopkins, Baltimore, Md

          4. Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Mn

          5. Dana Farber, Boston, Ma

          You can Google top hospitals for cancer and will get a more complete lest, however these are ranked the top 5.

          Jackie W

            LynnLuc
            Participant

              Jackie I went to Mayo in Rochester…they do NOT specialize in melanoma. I saw a breast cancer specialist.

              LynnLuc
              Participant

                Jackie I went to Mayo in Rochester…they do NOT specialize in melanoma. I saw a breast cancer specialist.

                LynnLuc
                Participant

                  PS I think your list comes from US News and that only gives Cancer hospitals in general and not melanoma.

                  LynnLuc
                  Participant

                    PS I think your list comes from US News and that only gives Cancer hospitals in general and not melanoma.

                    LynnLuc
                    Participant

                      PS I think your list comes from US News and that only gives Cancer hospitals in general and not melanoma.

                      LynnLuc
                      Participant

                        Jackie I went to Mayo in Rochester…they do NOT specialize in melanoma. I saw a breast cancer specialist.

                      jackiewin
                      Participant

                        The following is a list of the top 5 cancer hospitals in the US. 

                        1.  MD Anderson, Houston, Texas

                        2. Sloan Kettering, New York City

                        3. John Hopkins, Baltimore, Md

                        4. Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Mn

                        5. Dana Farber, Boston, Ma

                        You can Google top hospitals for cancer and will get a more complete lest, however these are ranked the top 5.

                        Jackie W

                        jackiewin
                        Participant

                          The following is a list of the top 5 cancer hospitals in the US. 

                          1.  MD Anderson, Houston, Texas

                          2. Sloan Kettering, New York City

                          3. John Hopkins, Baltimore, Md

                          4. Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Mn

                          5. Dana Farber, Boston, Ma

                          You can Google top hospitals for cancer and will get a more complete lest, however these are ranked the top 5.

                          Jackie W

                          Janner
                          Participant

                            Mucosal melanoma (vaginal) is quite rare so I would make sure you contact any place you are thinking of going to and ask them how many people they have treated with the same type of melanoma.  You might be able to do a long distance conference instead of flying there – at least at the start.  But if you can determine the best treatment options for that type of melanoma, you might find which centers have clinical trials or treatments geared toward mucosal melanoma.  No one cancer hospital really has better survival figures than any other – you are looking for a place that regularly treats mucosal melanoma and has treatments or clinical trials to further their research.  It would really pay you to do your legwork with those hospitals up front so you know if it is in your sister's best interest to fly that far for treatments. 

                            Best wishes,

                            Janner

                            Janner
                            Participant

                              Mucosal melanoma (vaginal) is quite rare so I would make sure you contact any place you are thinking of going to and ask them how many people they have treated with the same type of melanoma.  You might be able to do a long distance conference instead of flying there – at least at the start.  But if you can determine the best treatment options for that type of melanoma, you might find which centers have clinical trials or treatments geared toward mucosal melanoma.  No one cancer hospital really has better survival figures than any other – you are looking for a place that regularly treats mucosal melanoma and has treatments or clinical trials to further their research.  It would really pay you to do your legwork with those hospitals up front so you know if it is in your sister's best interest to fly that far for treatments. 

                              Best wishes,

                              Janner

                              Janner
                              Participant

                                Mucosal melanoma (vaginal) is quite rare so I would make sure you contact any place you are thinking of going to and ask them how many people they have treated with the same type of melanoma.  You might be able to do a long distance conference instead of flying there – at least at the start.  But if you can determine the best treatment options for that type of melanoma, you might find which centers have clinical trials or treatments geared toward mucosal melanoma.  No one cancer hospital really has better survival figures than any other – you are looking for a place that regularly treats mucosal melanoma and has treatments or clinical trials to further their research.  It would really pay you to do your legwork with those hospitals up front so you know if it is in your sister's best interest to fly that far for treatments. 

                                Best wishes,

                                Janner

                                WendyPam
                                Participant

                                  Hello,

                                  My Mother has Stage lV, Mucosal Melanoma of the Vulva. She is a young 69 year old. She is almost 3 year out with this diagnosis.  After having a radical bilateral vulvectomy followed by an intence month of interferon in Miami under the care of Dr. Jose Lutsky at Mount Sinai in Miami Beach. We are still under his care. My Mother had a recurrance exactly 10 months after her first surgery. She had a second surgery to remove lymph nodes in her groin area. After that the melanoma was removed from her outer stomach area.  She  does have some tumor activity in her lung and something on the outer stomach wall. She did complete 4 infusions of Yervoy July 19th and since her last PET scan she is showing lung activity smaller as well as outer stomach area smaller. I guess she is showing some response. My Mother had very heavy side effects from the Yervoy that her Dr said were very rare. She had terrible mouth sores as well as sores down her esophagus. This did not delay her Yervoy infusions. We see the Dr again on Dec 6th. He is talking about maybe operating on her again, but we are hoping to see even better results with our next scans. My Mother is both Braf-negative and C-kit negative. This is not uncommon for this type of mucosal melanoma. We have talked with the Dr if needed we would do a reinduction of Yervoy or get her into an Anti-pd1 trial. Dr. Lutzky was meeting with the people to maybe start a Anti-pd1L trial at his center. When I go with her on Dec 6th I will find out more about that. Through all of my readings and askings I have found that with mucosal melanoma if you are braf and c-kit negative the treatment is no different then all other melanoma patients.  Has your sister had her tumors tested yet? She should try and get Yervoy soon. Yes, this type of melanoma is very rare, but with all of todays treatment options your sister has a lot of living to do. If my Mother was to ever look for a second opion it would be Sloan in New York. However, we are very happy and comfortable with our Dr in Miami. Please feel free to ask me any question sthat might help you. I will be thinking of your sister and sending lots of love and prayers. You are truly a very special sister to her.

                                   

                                  Warm regards,

                                  Wendy

                                  WendyPam
                                  Participant

                                    Hello,

                                    My Mother has Stage lV, Mucosal Melanoma of the Vulva. She is a young 69 year old. She is almost 3 year out with this diagnosis.  After having a radical bilateral vulvectomy followed by an intence month of interferon in Miami under the care of Dr. Jose Lutsky at Mount Sinai in Miami Beach. We are still under his care. My Mother had a recurrance exactly 10 months after her first surgery. She had a second surgery to remove lymph nodes in her groin area. After that the melanoma was removed from her outer stomach area.  She  does have some tumor activity in her lung and something on the outer stomach wall. She did complete 4 infusions of Yervoy July 19th and since her last PET scan she is showing lung activity smaller as well as outer stomach area smaller. I guess she is showing some response. My Mother had very heavy side effects from the Yervoy that her Dr said were very rare. She had terrible mouth sores as well as sores down her esophagus. This did not delay her Yervoy infusions. We see the Dr again on Dec 6th. He is talking about maybe operating on her again, but we are hoping to see even better results with our next scans. My Mother is both Braf-negative and C-kit negative. This is not uncommon for this type of mucosal melanoma. We have talked with the Dr if needed we would do a reinduction of Yervoy or get her into an Anti-pd1 trial. Dr. Lutzky was meeting with the people to maybe start a Anti-pd1L trial at his center. When I go with her on Dec 6th I will find out more about that. Through all of my readings and askings I have found that with mucosal melanoma if you are braf and c-kit negative the treatment is no different then all other melanoma patients.  Has your sister had her tumors tested yet? She should try and get Yervoy soon. Yes, this type of melanoma is very rare, but with all of todays treatment options your sister has a lot of living to do. If my Mother was to ever look for a second opion it would be Sloan in New York. However, we are very happy and comfortable with our Dr in Miami. Please feel free to ask me any question sthat might help you. I will be thinking of your sister and sending lots of love and prayers. You are truly a very special sister to her.

                                     

                                    Warm regards,

                                    Wendy

                                    WendyPam
                                    Participant

                                      Hello,

                                      My Mother has Stage lV, Mucosal Melanoma of the Vulva. She is a young 69 year old. She is almost 3 year out with this diagnosis.  After having a radical bilateral vulvectomy followed by an intence month of interferon in Miami under the care of Dr. Jose Lutsky at Mount Sinai in Miami Beach. We are still under his care. My Mother had a recurrance exactly 10 months after her first surgery. She had a second surgery to remove lymph nodes in her groin area. After that the melanoma was removed from her outer stomach area.  She  does have some tumor activity in her lung and something on the outer stomach wall. She did complete 4 infusions of Yervoy July 19th and since her last PET scan she is showing lung activity smaller as well as outer stomach area smaller. I guess she is showing some response. My Mother had very heavy side effects from the Yervoy that her Dr said were very rare. She had terrible mouth sores as well as sores down her esophagus. This did not delay her Yervoy infusions. We see the Dr again on Dec 6th. He is talking about maybe operating on her again, but we are hoping to see even better results with our next scans. My Mother is both Braf-negative and C-kit negative. This is not uncommon for this type of mucosal melanoma. We have talked with the Dr if needed we would do a reinduction of Yervoy or get her into an Anti-pd1 trial. Dr. Lutzky was meeting with the people to maybe start a Anti-pd1L trial at his center. When I go with her on Dec 6th I will find out more about that. Through all of my readings and askings I have found that with mucosal melanoma if you are braf and c-kit negative the treatment is no different then all other melanoma patients.  Has your sister had her tumors tested yet? She should try and get Yervoy soon. Yes, this type of melanoma is very rare, but with all of todays treatment options your sister has a lot of living to do. If my Mother was to ever look for a second opion it would be Sloan in New York. However, we are very happy and comfortable with our Dr in Miami. Please feel free to ask me any question sthat might help you. I will be thinking of your sister and sending lots of love and prayers. You are truly a very special sister to her.

                                       

                                      Warm regards,

                                      Wendy

                                      boot2aboot
                                      Participant

                                        i've had good luck at moffitt…vanderbilt is another good one as well as dana farber…melanoma treatment requires repeated trips to doctors office so i would probably pick the closest one to your home…which would likely be dana farber.

                                        boot2aboot
                                        Participant

                                          i've had good luck at moffitt…vanderbilt is another good one as well as dana farber…melanoma treatment requires repeated trips to doctors office so i would probably pick the closest one to your home…which would likely be dana farber.

                                          boot2aboot
                                          Participant

                                            i've had good luck at moffitt…vanderbilt is another good one as well as dana farber…melanoma treatment requires repeated trips to doctors office so i would probably pick the closest one to your home…which would likely be dana farber.

                                            Janner
                                            Participant

                                              One other thing – you may consider looking at doctors and centers in Australia.  That's certainly closer to you.  Australia has the highest incidence of melanoma in the world and certainly has fine centers for treatment.  If a treatment you seek is offered there, it might be a better choice.  Just thought I'd throw this out there for consideration.

                                              Best wishes,

                                              Janner

                                              Janner
                                              Participant

                                                One other thing – you may consider looking at doctors and centers in Australia.  That's certainly closer to you.  Australia has the highest incidence of melanoma in the world and certainly has fine centers for treatment.  If a treatment you seek is offered there, it might be a better choice.  Just thought I'd throw this out there for consideration.

                                                Best wishes,

                                                Janner

                                                Janner
                                                Participant

                                                  One other thing – you may consider looking at doctors and centers in Australia.  That's certainly closer to you.  Australia has the highest incidence of melanoma in the world and certainly has fine centers for treatment.  If a treatment you seek is offered there, it might be a better choice.  Just thought I'd throw this out there for consideration.

                                                  Best wishes,

                                                  Janner

                                                  shellebrownies
                                                  Participant

                                                    If you are looking into the possibility of coming to Boston, then you should also look into Mass General Cancer Center (#6 on that list of best cancer hospitals, right behind Dana Farber). My husband and I had a phenomenal experience there. Both Dr. Flaherty and Dr. Lawrence have tons of years of experience.

                                                    Michelle

                                                    shellebrownies
                                                    Participant

                                                      If you are looking into the possibility of coming to Boston, then you should also look into Mass General Cancer Center (#6 on that list of best cancer hospitals, right behind Dana Farber). My husband and I had a phenomenal experience there. Both Dr. Flaherty and Dr. Lawrence have tons of years of experience.

                                                      Michelle

                                                      shellebrownies
                                                      Participant

                                                        If you are looking into the possibility of coming to Boston, then you should also look into Mass General Cancer Center (#6 on that list of best cancer hospitals, right behind Dana Farber). My husband and I had a phenomenal experience there. Both Dr. Flaherty and Dr. Lawrence have tons of years of experience.

                                                        Michelle

                                                        LynnLuc
                                                        Participant

                                                          You could e-mail Dr Weber at Moffitt and ask if they deal with it. [email protected]   He will give you a quick response. I personally believe and perhaps it is because I am in a trial there and NED that its the best!

                                                          LynnLuc
                                                          Participant

                                                            You could e-mail Dr Weber at Moffitt and ask if they deal with it. [email protected]   He will give you a quick response. I personally believe and perhaps it is because I am in a trial there and NED that its the best!

                                                            LynnLuc
                                                            Participant

                                                              You could e-mail Dr Weber at Moffitt and ask if they deal with it. [email protected]   He will give you a quick response. I personally believe and perhaps it is because I am in a trial there and NED that its the best!

                                                          Viewing 23 reply threads
                                                          • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
                                                          About the MRF Patient Forum

                                                          The MRF Patient Forum is the oldest and largest online community of people affected by melanoma. It is designed to provide peer support and information to caregivers, patients, family and friends. There is no better place to discuss different parts of your journey with this cancer and find the friends and support resources to make that journey more bearable.

                                                          The information on the forum is open and accessible to everyone. To add a new topic or to post a reply, you must be a registered user. Please note that you will be able to post both topics and replies anonymously even though you are logged in. All posts must abide by MRF posting policies.

                                                          Popular Topics