The information on this site is not intended or implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Content within the patient forum is user-generated and has not been reviewed by medical professionals. Other sections of the Melanoma Research Foundation website include information that has been reviewed by medical professionals as appropriate. All medical decisions should be made in consultation with your doctor or other qualified medical professional.

New Member and confused

Forums General Melanoma Community New Member and confused

  • Post
    dolphin5
    Participant

      My wife was found to have four tumors all positive for melanoma.  Three have been removed with clear margins.  One in the breast, lung and buttocks.  One was left in her neck with the theory of wait and watch, which she does not like.  The primary was never found.  All have the marker of HMB45, S100 and Melan-A.  This is our question.  What do these markers mean and do they determine future treatment.  Finally does it sound reasonable to wait and watch.  

      My wife was found to have four tumors all positive for melanoma.  Three have been removed with clear margins.  One in the breast, lung and buttocks.  One was left in her neck with the theory of wait and watch, which she does not like.  The primary was never found.  All have the marker of HMB45, S100 and Melan-A.  This is our question.  What do these markers mean and do they determine future treatment.  Finally does it sound reasonable to wait and watch.  

    Viewing 11 reply threads
    • Replies
        Janner
        Participant

          The markers mean nothing in regards to treatment.  Essentially, they are different "stains" used on the pathology slides.   If a tumor is positive for these different stains, it is justifying the diagnosis that this is a melanoma tumor.  These are for diagnostic purposes and not treatment related.

          Is your wife being seen by a melanoma specialist?  Watch and wait isn't the typical scenario when you are stage IV and have active disease.  There are times a tumor may be left in place while doing a new treatment so it is easy to monitor if the treatment is effective.  That makes sense.  But at least to me, I would not be comfortable just watching and doing no treatment.  There are new drugs available for treatment melanoma as well as clinical trials.  I suggest doing more research on Yervoy (IPILIMUMAB), Zelboraf (for BRAF positive markers on a tumor), IL-2 (Interleukin 2) or any number of clinical trials available.  (www.clinicaltrials.gov).  I would definitely head to a larger cancer center and melanoma specialist if at all possible.  At the very least, request a second opinion.

          Best wishes,

          Janner

          Janner
          Participant

            The markers mean nothing in regards to treatment.  Essentially, they are different "stains" used on the pathology slides.   If a tumor is positive for these different stains, it is justifying the diagnosis that this is a melanoma tumor.  These are for diagnostic purposes and not treatment related.

            Is your wife being seen by a melanoma specialist?  Watch and wait isn't the typical scenario when you are stage IV and have active disease.  There are times a tumor may be left in place while doing a new treatment so it is easy to monitor if the treatment is effective.  That makes sense.  But at least to me, I would not be comfortable just watching and doing no treatment.  There are new drugs available for treatment melanoma as well as clinical trials.  I suggest doing more research on Yervoy (IPILIMUMAB), Zelboraf (for BRAF positive markers on a tumor), IL-2 (Interleukin 2) or any number of clinical trials available.  (www.clinicaltrials.gov).  I would definitely head to a larger cancer center and melanoma specialist if at all possible.  At the very least, request a second opinion.

            Best wishes,

            Janner

            Janner
            Participant

              The markers mean nothing in regards to treatment.  Essentially, they are different "stains" used on the pathology slides.   If a tumor is positive for these different stains, it is justifying the diagnosis that this is a melanoma tumor.  These are for diagnostic purposes and not treatment related.

              Is your wife being seen by a melanoma specialist?  Watch and wait isn't the typical scenario when you are stage IV and have active disease.  There are times a tumor may be left in place while doing a new treatment so it is easy to monitor if the treatment is effective.  That makes sense.  But at least to me, I would not be comfortable just watching and doing no treatment.  There are new drugs available for treatment melanoma as well as clinical trials.  I suggest doing more research on Yervoy (IPILIMUMAB), Zelboraf (for BRAF positive markers on a tumor), IL-2 (Interleukin 2) or any number of clinical trials available.  (www.clinicaltrials.gov).  I would definitely head to a larger cancer center and melanoma specialist if at all possible.  At the very least, request a second opinion.

              Best wishes,

              Janner

              POW
              Participant

                Janner is absolutely correct, as usual. "Watch and wait" is NOT the way to go with a Stage IV melanoma! You definitely need to get a consult with a melanoma specialist, preferably at a Melanoma Center of Excellence. Where are you located? 

                POW
                Participant

                  Janner is absolutely correct, as usual. "Watch and wait" is NOT the way to go with a Stage IV melanoma! You definitely need to get a consult with a melanoma specialist, preferably at a Melanoma Center of Excellence. Where are you located? 

                  POW
                  Participant

                    Janner is absolutely correct, as usual. "Watch and wait" is NOT the way to go with a Stage IV melanoma! You definitely need to get a consult with a melanoma specialist, preferably at a Melanoma Center of Excellence. Where are you located? 

                    Linny
                    Participant

                      Definitely seek a second opinion at a melanoma clinic/center of excellence. Based on what you just said, watch and wait doesn't sound right.

                      Linny
                      Participant

                        Definitely seek a second opinion at a melanoma clinic/center of excellence. Based on what you just said, watch and wait doesn't sound right.

                        Linny
                        Participant

                          Definitely seek a second opinion at a melanoma clinic/center of excellence. Based on what you just said, watch and wait doesn't sound right.

                          kylez
                          Participant

                            Agree with the others. To find a melanoma specialist, try the "Find the Right Doctor" list at the Aim at Melanoma web site: http://www.aimatmelanoma.org/en/aim-for-answers/path-to-getting-a-diagnosis/finding-the-right-doctor.html It makes a huge difference to have an oncologist who specializes in melanoma, we've seen that here over and over.

                            One thing having unresected, still meausurable disease could do is help you to qualify you for a clinical trial. It's not clear that's what the intent was in your case, however, since you didn't mention that as an intent.

                            kylez
                            Participant

                              Agree with the others. To find a melanoma specialist, try the "Find the Right Doctor" list at the Aim at Melanoma web site: http://www.aimatmelanoma.org/en/aim-for-answers/path-to-getting-a-diagnosis/finding-the-right-doctor.html It makes a huge difference to have an oncologist who specializes in melanoma, we've seen that here over and over.

                              One thing having unresected, still meausurable disease could do is help you to qualify you for a clinical trial. It's not clear that's what the intent was in your case, however, since you didn't mention that as an intent.

                              kylez
                              Participant

                                Agree with the others. To find a melanoma specialist, try the "Find the Right Doctor" list at the Aim at Melanoma web site: http://www.aimatmelanoma.org/en/aim-for-answers/path-to-getting-a-diagnosis/finding-the-right-doctor.html It makes a huge difference to have an oncologist who specializes in melanoma, we've seen that here over and over.

                                One thing having unresected, still meausurable disease could do is help you to qualify you for a clinical trial. It's not clear that's what the intent was in your case, however, since you didn't mention that as an intent.

                            Viewing 11 reply threads
                            • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
                            About the MRF Patient Forum

                            The MRF Patient Forum is the oldest and largest online community of people affected by melanoma. It is designed to provide peer support and information to caregivers, patients, family and friends. There is no better place to discuss different parts of your journey with this cancer and find the friends and support resources to make that journey more bearable.

                            The information on the forum is open and accessible to everyone. To add a new topic or to post a reply, you must be a registered user. Please note that you will be able to post both topics and replies anonymously even though you are logged in. All posts must abide by MRF posting policies.

                            Popular Topics