› Forums › General Melanoma Community › Jane Patten’s touted Perseus Clinic Trial
- This topic has 54 replies, 7 voices, and was last updated 10 years, 1 month ago by
Cooper.
- Post
-
- January 29, 2015 at 4:23 am
To be precise: https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02301611?term=Elios&rank=1
I was diagnosed with melanoma in 2003. I progressed to Stage IV with brain and lung mets in 2010. I was lucky enough to participate in a Nivo trial in 2010. I remain NED. I am for anything…and I mean ANYTHING!!!!!!… that will help patients with melanoma. I think most of you know that…and me…very well. However, I am equally passionate about those who would use melanoma…and the fear that such a diagnosis creates…to make money, reputation, whatever craziness they have in their own heads…at the expense of patients and families that are suffering. When Ms. Patten first promoted her grand melanoma treatment…I thought: What??? This is weird. I've been living in melanoma world a long time and this trial/treatment has no rep what-so-ever with Ribas, Sosman, Flaherty, Weber, Wolchok, Sznol, Pavlick, etc. BUT….let me check….
Here is what my husband found after many hours of research. We both present it here:
Dear Tim and the rest of you depending on this board…
I am writing to alert you to a possible scam unfolding on the MRF site. Twice last week, and twice today, a poster using the name “Jane Patten” and “anonymous” proffered a clinical trial for melanoma using autologous vaccine with dendritic cells prepared via a technique patented by a Dr. Wagner who runs a clinic in the Cayman Islands. The medical director of the Perseus Clinic is Dr. George Peoples who is also the CEO of Cancer Insight, LLC. Cancer Insight is sponsoring the clinical trials in the US. However, some of the Phase 1 and Phase 2 data used for their application was derived from patients in the Cayman Islands. Perseus pays patients $10,000.00 to participate in these trials. The data available for the Phase 1 trial from the Perseus website is garbled and looks as though the response rate is significantly less than that achieved by other available options like Yervoy, anti-pd1 and even IL2. There are only 23 evaluable patients in the cohort. Of these, 4 were NED at the start of the trial. However, since all 4 NED patients survived for the length of the study, when they are averaged in with the other patients, they skew the survival figures. According to Perseus data, with patients presenting initially as Stage II-IV, the progression free survival was only 12.4% at 30 months. This is no better than what is historically reported for Stage IV melanoma patients generally. The published data in the paper: Dendritoma Vaccine for Cancer: A Hopeful Approach. Wei, Li, Wagner. Current Cancer Therapy Reviews. 2009. [Check it!!! 2009, people!!!!!!!!] touted by the Perseus web site, using their specific vaccine preparation in conjunction with IL2 in their clinical trial, demonstrates a much worse response than other trials with dendritic autologous vaccines to date. The Phase I trial of Stage IV melanoma patients had only 1 complete response and 2 stable disease events out of 10 patients. Length of response is not stated. The Phase II study had a progression free survival of 5.5 months which is less than what is expected for Stage IV melanoma patients with NO TREATMENT!!!!! The progression free survival at 5 years was 2 patients out of 15 (or 13%). The Perseus web site also presents an “infographic” which states that there is “increased life expectancy across the board”. This is illustrated by a “90% 6.5 month survival after treatment, 33% after 5 years and 10% after 12 years”. Nowhere does it indicate the Stage of the patient, other treatments utilized, etc. ALL of the “data” is based on 25 patients with melanoma. No other reputable melanoma oncologist or researcher presents such a vague and misleading face to their care/data. This trial, its proponents, and results are not credible. These posts are an obvious sales pitch. Sadly, this represents a deplorable scam. Brent Morris, M.D.
Obviously, each of you will have to choose what is best for you and yours. We have both dedicated a large part of our personal time and effort, with no agenda other than the best possible care and treatment, to melanoma patients (near and far) for many years. Do what you think is best for you. But, with the predatory nature of Ms. Patten's posts….we thought it best that you see the data for yourselves.
Wishing you all our best – Celeste and Brent Morris
- Replies
-
-
- January 29, 2015 at 5:11 am
Just in case they take this down later: http://www.melanomaregistry.com/new-registry-opens/
See the payments for yourself. C
-
- January 29, 2015 at 5:11 am
Just in case they take this down later: http://www.melanomaregistry.com/new-registry-opens/
See the payments for yourself. C
-
- January 29, 2015 at 5:17 am
The way I read the information on the page you linked above, Perseus is requiring $10K from any patient wishing to enroll in the trial. They will "subsidize" the additional $40K they say the treatment is worth.
Sounds fishy to me.
-
- January 29, 2015 at 5:17 am
The way I read the information on the page you linked above, Perseus is requiring $10K from any patient wishing to enroll in the trial. They will "subsidize" the additional $40K they say the treatment is worth.
Sounds fishy to me.
-
- January 29, 2015 at 5:17 am
The way I read the information on the page you linked above, Perseus is requiring $10K from any patient wishing to enroll in the trial. They will "subsidize" the additional $40K they say the treatment is worth.
Sounds fishy to me.
-
- January 29, 2015 at 5:11 am
Just in case they take this down later: http://www.melanomaregistry.com/new-registry-opens/
See the payments for yourself. C
-
- January 29, 2015 at 5:31 am
In case it has been unclear….in order to make the vaccine…your tumor is removed…often making the patient NED. My point is this….with the tumor in place…these melanoma patients qualify for: BRAF inhibitors (if BRAF positive), ipi, anti-PD1 (both Keytruda and Opdivo)…all FDA approved treatments with much better response rates than those touted with this vaccine. Not to mention…the prospect of a wide variety of other trials…including the ipi/nivo combo now in clinical trials that by renowned melanoma experts have "the best numbers" going. There are also trials for NED/adjuvant patients (like my own with nivo/vaccines) ongoing. The adjuvant ipi trial had a 70% 5 year survivial rate. The nivo trial had similar…if not better…results. Here are links to show that though my head my be holey after SRS…I can still read what's on the page:
https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02301611?term=Elios&rank=1
http://www.perseuspci.com/patients/works/
So…decide for yourself….but snake oil is still for sale. Or….maybe even at a reduced rate in the Cayman's!
Hang in there, ratties. C
-
- January 29, 2015 at 5:31 am
In case it has been unclear….in order to make the vaccine…your tumor is removed…often making the patient NED. My point is this….with the tumor in place…these melanoma patients qualify for: BRAF inhibitors (if BRAF positive), ipi, anti-PD1 (both Keytruda and Opdivo)…all FDA approved treatments with much better response rates than those touted with this vaccine. Not to mention…the prospect of a wide variety of other trials…including the ipi/nivo combo now in clinical trials that by renowned melanoma experts have "the best numbers" going. There are also trials for NED/adjuvant patients (like my own with nivo/vaccines) ongoing. The adjuvant ipi trial had a 70% 5 year survivial rate. The nivo trial had similar…if not better…results. Here are links to show that though my head my be holey after SRS…I can still read what's on the page:
https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02301611?term=Elios&rank=1
http://www.perseuspci.com/patients/works/
So…decide for yourself….but snake oil is still for sale. Or….maybe even at a reduced rate in the Cayman's!
Hang in there, ratties. C
-
- January 29, 2015 at 5:31 am
In case it has been unclear….in order to make the vaccine…your tumor is removed…often making the patient NED. My point is this….with the tumor in place…these melanoma patients qualify for: BRAF inhibitors (if BRAF positive), ipi, anti-PD1 (both Keytruda and Opdivo)…all FDA approved treatments with much better response rates than those touted with this vaccine. Not to mention…the prospect of a wide variety of other trials…including the ipi/nivo combo now in clinical trials that by renowned melanoma experts have "the best numbers" going. There are also trials for NED/adjuvant patients (like my own with nivo/vaccines) ongoing. The adjuvant ipi trial had a 70% 5 year survivial rate. The nivo trial had similar…if not better…results. Here are links to show that though my head my be holey after SRS…I can still read what's on the page:
https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02301611?term=Elios&rank=1
http://www.perseuspci.com/patients/works/
So…decide for yourself….but snake oil is still for sale. Or….maybe even at a reduced rate in the Cayman's!
Hang in there, ratties. C
-
- January 29, 2015 at 10:42 am
I know I am going off topic here, but Bubbles your post reads your were on a drug called Nivo, would that be the same as Nivolumab, as my young sister is travelling to Brisbane as we speak to start this new drug, she has mets to her lungs and brain and although the combo drug she was on is doing its job in her lungs its having no impact on the brain mets, thats why her Onc now starting her on this, would so love to hear your views on it, if indeed it is the drug you were on. She's my little hero and I am her support person, its so hard for us all as she lives in Australia with her kids and husband and we all live in Ireland so we trying to be the best support we can from here.
-
- January 29, 2015 at 10:42 am
I know I am going off topic here, but Bubbles your post reads your were on a drug called Nivo, would that be the same as Nivolumab, as my young sister is travelling to Brisbane as we speak to start this new drug, she has mets to her lungs and brain and although the combo drug she was on is doing its job in her lungs its having no impact on the brain mets, thats why her Onc now starting her on this, would so love to hear your views on it, if indeed it is the drug you were on. She's my little hero and I am her support person, its so hard for us all as she lives in Australia with her kids and husband and we all live in Ireland so we trying to be the best support we can from here.
-
- January 29, 2015 at 2:20 pm
No problem, Porrige. Your sister is more important than the other stuff anyway!!! Rick is right. Nivolumab is one of the many names given to the BMS anti-PD1 product. It is currently licensed under the name Opdivo. Merck has an anti-PD1 product that was once called Pembrolizumab and is now licensed as Keytruda. Here are some posts that might help you understand anti-PD1 generally.
Rick is also correct that there is a wealth of information on this site. I wish your sister well. Yours, Celeste
-
- January 29, 2015 at 2:20 pm
No problem, Porrige. Your sister is more important than the other stuff anyway!!! Rick is right. Nivolumab is one of the many names given to the BMS anti-PD1 product. It is currently licensed under the name Opdivo. Merck has an anti-PD1 product that was once called Pembrolizumab and is now licensed as Keytruda. Here are some posts that might help you understand anti-PD1 generally.
Rick is also correct that there is a wealth of information on this site. I wish your sister well. Yours, Celeste
-
- January 30, 2015 at 10:41 am
Hi Guys, Bubbles,
Thanks for your lovely warm replies, have just come off the phone this minute with my sister and she in floods of tears, while at the hospital she had a brain seizure and even though it was mild enough she is now not allowed to have the drug, so as we speak they are now prepping her for radiation to the brain a mask has been made for her and she starts in awhile she is having three doses over the next three days so as you can imagine I cannot cuddle and kiss her only write and write and phone so its very hard, but she has an amazing husband who will see her through this all I can hope for is that if as the Docs said they can stabilise her she could get the drug later on please God. x
-
- January 30, 2015 at 10:41 am
Hi Guys, Bubbles,
Thanks for your lovely warm replies, have just come off the phone this minute with my sister and she in floods of tears, while at the hospital she had a brain seizure and even though it was mild enough she is now not allowed to have the drug, so as we speak they are now prepping her for radiation to the brain a mask has been made for her and she starts in awhile she is having three doses over the next three days so as you can imagine I cannot cuddle and kiss her only write and write and phone so its very hard, but she has an amazing husband who will see her through this all I can hope for is that if as the Docs said they can stabilise her she could get the drug later on please God. x
-
- January 30, 2015 at 10:41 am
Hi Guys, Bubbles,
Thanks for your lovely warm replies, have just come off the phone this minute with my sister and she in floods of tears, while at the hospital she had a brain seizure and even though it was mild enough she is now not allowed to have the drug, so as we speak they are now prepping her for radiation to the brain a mask has been made for her and she starts in awhile she is having three doses over the next three days so as you can imagine I cannot cuddle and kiss her only write and write and phone so its very hard, but she has an amazing husband who will see her through this all I can hope for is that if as the Docs said they can stabilise her she could get the drug later on please God. x
-
- January 30, 2015 at 2:35 pm
Hi,
My wife had started Pembrolizumab/Keytruda but then developed brain mets. She just finished her 5th whole brain radiation treatment today (we got to take the mask home LOL!) and we expect to continue on the immunotherapy next Wednesday.
Try not to panic, and push to get the Keytruda started asap after the brain radiation!
Wish you good luck – and for your sister!
Rick
-
- January 30, 2015 at 2:35 pm
Hi,
My wife had started Pembrolizumab/Keytruda but then developed brain mets. She just finished her 5th whole brain radiation treatment today (we got to take the mask home LOL!) and we expect to continue on the immunotherapy next Wednesday.
Try not to panic, and push to get the Keytruda started asap after the brain radiation!
Wish you good luck – and for your sister!
Rick
-
- January 30, 2015 at 2:35 pm
Hi,
My wife had started Pembrolizumab/Keytruda but then developed brain mets. She just finished her 5th whole brain radiation treatment today (we got to take the mask home LOL!) and we expect to continue on the immunotherapy next Wednesday.
Try not to panic, and push to get the Keytruda started asap after the brain radiation!
Wish you good luck – and for your sister!
Rick
-
- January 29, 2015 at 2:20 pm
No problem, Porrige. Your sister is more important than the other stuff anyway!!! Rick is right. Nivolumab is one of the many names given to the BMS anti-PD1 product. It is currently licensed under the name Opdivo. Merck has an anti-PD1 product that was once called Pembrolizumab and is now licensed as Keytruda. Here are some posts that might help you understand anti-PD1 generally.
Rick is also correct that there is a wealth of information on this site. I wish your sister well. Yours, Celeste
-
- January 29, 2015 at 8:00 pm
Hi porridge. So sorry to hear about your sister. There is a dr Georgina long in Sydney and I heard that she recently presented a paper on the new PD1 drugs and her research showed significant improvement in the brain mets on these drugs and all the doctors at the conference were standing and whooping and cheering at the results. Sorry I don't have a link or something
jubes
-
- January 29, 2015 at 8:00 pm
Hi porridge. So sorry to hear about your sister. There is a dr Georgina long in Sydney and I heard that she recently presented a paper on the new PD1 drugs and her research showed significant improvement in the brain mets on these drugs and all the doctors at the conference were standing and whooping and cheering at the results. Sorry I don't have a link or something
jubes
-
- January 29, 2015 at 8:00 pm
Hi porridge. So sorry to hear about your sister. There is a dr Georgina long in Sydney and I heard that she recently presented a paper on the new PD1 drugs and her research showed significant improvement in the brain mets on these drugs and all the doctors at the conference were standing and whooping and cheering at the results. Sorry I don't have a link or something
jubes
-
- January 29, 2015 at 8:55 pm
Hi porridge. So sorry to hear about your sister. There is a dr Georgina long in Sydney and I heard that she recently presented a paper on the new PD1 drugs and her research showed significant improvement in the brain mets on these drugs and all the doctors at the conference were standing and whooping and cheering at the results. Sorry I don't have a link or something
jubes
-
- January 29, 2015 at 8:55 pm
Hi porridge. So sorry to hear about your sister. There is a dr Georgina long in Sydney and I heard that she recently presented a paper on the new PD1 drugs and her research showed significant improvement in the brain mets on these drugs and all the doctors at the conference were standing and whooping and cheering at the results. Sorry I don't have a link or something
jubes
-
- January 29, 2015 at 8:55 pm
Hi porridge. So sorry to hear about your sister. There is a dr Georgina long in Sydney and I heard that she recently presented a paper on the new PD1 drugs and her research showed significant improvement in the brain mets on these drugs and all the doctors at the conference were standing and whooping and cheering at the results. Sorry I don't have a link or something
jubes
-
- January 30, 2015 at 11:47 am
Thanks Jubes,
Feeling the support here in Ireland from you all Tis great. Have copied your information this minute on to her husband, when the these radiation sessions are done, it would be fantastic if she could get the Nivo, all we need now is to get her stabilised in order to pass this criteria for the drug.
-
- January 30, 2015 at 11:47 am
Thanks Jubes,
Feeling the support here in Ireland from you all Tis great. Have copied your information this minute on to her husband, when the these radiation sessions are done, it would be fantastic if she could get the Nivo, all we need now is to get her stabilised in order to pass this criteria for the drug.
-
- January 30, 2015 at 2:18 pm
Porrige,
So sorry your sister has had this setback. I know it is very frightening for her and for all who love her. I dealt with brain and lung mets before taking anti-PD1. While it is not what I would recommend for anyone!!!!, it certainly can be done and I bet your sister will come through like a trooper. But, perhaps more importantly, I wanted to let you know that your love and support can be felt by your sister no matter the distance. When going through some of my most difficult times, I felt the care and concern sent to me by others like a beautiful blanket, keeping me safe and warm. When it is real, love comes through…no matter its delivery method. Yours, Celeste
-
- January 30, 2015 at 2:18 pm
Porrige,
So sorry your sister has had this setback. I know it is very frightening for her and for all who love her. I dealt with brain and lung mets before taking anti-PD1. While it is not what I would recommend for anyone!!!!, it certainly can be done and I bet your sister will come through like a trooper. But, perhaps more importantly, I wanted to let you know that your love and support can be felt by your sister no matter the distance. When going through some of my most difficult times, I felt the care and concern sent to me by others like a beautiful blanket, keeping me safe and warm. When it is real, love comes through…no matter its delivery method. Yours, Celeste
-
- January 30, 2015 at 2:18 pm
Porrige,
So sorry your sister has had this setback. I know it is very frightening for her and for all who love her. I dealt with brain and lung mets before taking anti-PD1. While it is not what I would recommend for anyone!!!!, it certainly can be done and I bet your sister will come through like a trooper. But, perhaps more importantly, I wanted to let you know that your love and support can be felt by your sister no matter the distance. When going through some of my most difficult times, I felt the care and concern sent to me by others like a beautiful blanket, keeping me safe and warm. When it is real, love comes through…no matter its delivery method. Yours, Celeste
-
- January 30, 2015 at 11:47 am
Thanks Jubes,
Feeling the support here in Ireland from you all Tis great. Have copied your information this minute on to her husband, when the these radiation sessions are done, it would be fantastic if she could get the Nivo, all we need now is to get her stabilised in order to pass this criteria for the drug.
-
- January 29, 2015 at 10:42 am
I know I am going off topic here, but Bubbles your post reads your were on a drug called Nivo, would that be the same as Nivolumab, as my young sister is travelling to Brisbane as we speak to start this new drug, she has mets to her lungs and brain and although the combo drug she was on is doing its job in her lungs its having no impact on the brain mets, thats why her Onc now starting her on this, would so love to hear your views on it, if indeed it is the drug you were on. She's my little hero and I am her support person, its so hard for us all as she lives in Australia with her kids and husband and we all live in Ireland so we trying to be the best support we can from here.
-
- January 30, 2015 at 5:18 am
Thanks for all the time and effort you put into this!
-
- February 3, 2015 at 2:21 am
Good try, Cooper. But actually, here's the history of sentinel node determination and biopsy:
"The concept of a sentinel node was first described by Gould et al. 1960 in a patient with cancer of the parotid gland and was implemented clinically on a broad scale by Cabanas in penile cancer. The technique of sentinel node radiolocalization was co-founded by James C. Alex, MD, FACS and David N. Krag MD (University of Vermont Medical Center) and they were the first ones to pioneer this technique for the use of cutaneous melanoma, breast cancer, head and neck cancer and Merkel cell carcinoma. Confirmative trials followed soon after. Studies were also conducted at the Moffitt Cancer Center with Charles Cox, MD, Douglas Reintgen, MD and James Norman, MD."
Additionally, I wish that when a trial gains approval and is listed via ClinicalTrials.gov we could KNOW that it would benefit us all. Sadly…that just aint so. Just recently an approved trial combining BRAFi and ipi had to be stopped due to liver toxicity. Various approved trials still use dacarbazine and interferon as the comparative agent…when most ALL the melanoma big dogs have gone on record stating that those are outdated since BRAFi, ipi, and the anti-PD1 products have gained FDA approval. Innumerable vaccine trials have been halted due to their lack of effect. Maybe someday a vaccine will be the cure. That would be fabulous. But, this particular one doesn't have the data to prove that it has any better response rate than the IL2 it is combined with. And that's from the data the trial proponents have published.
Have a good one Coop!! If you or anyone else want to give this one a whirl….go for it. Just wanted folks to be able to make informed choices. c
-
- February 3, 2015 at 6:18 pm
- 'Practice Changing' MRI Recommendations in Multiple Myeloma
EGFR Mutant Lung Cancer: Lessons From ASPIRATION and IMPRESS
Second-line Oxaliplatin Benefits Pancreatic Cancer Patients
Salivary Gland Cancer: Teamwork Pays Off
Return to ArticleTributes Flow for Sentinel Lymph Node Biopsy Inventor Donald Morton, MD
Kate Johnson
January 23, 2014
Drug & Reference InformationAn icon in surgical oncology passed away this week. Donald Morton, MD, who died from heart failure at the age of 79 years, is credited with changing the direction of cancer treatment by mapping the course of malignant melanoma with his identification of the sentinel lymph node. He also pioneered the development of cancer vaccines.
"It's a huge loss in the cancer world," Anton Bilchik, MD, PhD, told Medscape Medical News. Dr. Bilchik is chief of medicine at the John Wayne Cancer Institute in Santa Monica, California, an institution founded and previously headed by Dr. Morton, who was recently chief of the melanoma program.
Dr. Donald Morton"He was a giant in the field," said Armando E. Giuliano, MD, professor of surgery and associate director of the Samuel Oschin Comprehensive Cancer Center at Cedars-Sinai in Los Angeles, also speaking in an interview.
Both Dr. Bilchik and Dr. Giuliano worked alongside Dr. Morton for many years.
"He was still working and funded by the National Cancer Institute up until the end," said Dr. Giuliano. "He continued to see patients and operate until quite recently. He was loved by his patients."
"He was one of the pioneers of modern cancer research," said Dr. Bilchik. "The [sentinel lymph node] technique that he discovered for melanoma, and which he published in the New England Journal of Medicine, has become the standard of care for the treatment of melanoma around the world, and has saved many people unnecessary lymph node dissections. That concept was then applied to breast cancer, and the first sentinel lymph node procedure for breast cancer was done at the John Wayne Cancer Institute. That, too, became the standard of care for the management of early breast cancer, and now many women around the world have not had to undergo unnecessary lymph node dissections because of that. So his work has really had a tremendous impact on the management of melanoma and breast cancer, and has been applied to improving staging for colon cancer, stomach cancer, and esophageal cancer."
Dr. Morton was also a major contributor to immunotherapy in cancer, said Dr. Giuliano. "His intravesicalar injections of metastatic melanoma to the bladder led the way for BCG treatment of bladder cancer — the first FDA-approved form of cancer immunotherapy. His work on cancer vaccines led to NIH funding for a large prospective randomized trial of an antimelanoma vaccine, which he developed. Dr. Morton was also a pioneer in limb-salvage surgery for soft tissue sarcoma and pulmonary resection for solid tumor metastases."
Teaching and sharing his knowledge was a central preoccupation for Dr. Morton, who, over the course of his career, trained more than 140 surgical fellows.
"There are few people in the world who have trained as many people in cancer as he has," said Dr. Bilchik. "More than 80% of those fellows are now leaders in surgery or cancer research. Many of them are deans, heads of departments, or chairs."
At the same time, Dr. Morton had an extraordinary ability to strike a personal rapport with his patients.
"Many surgeons will operate on a patient, maybe see them postoperatively, and then they'll get followed by their internist or oncologist. But he made a point of following every one of his patients and had a personal relationship with every one of his patients. Many patients would see him who he'd operated on 30 or 40 years ago," said Dr. Bilchik.
An obituary published in the Los Angeles Daily News quotes Dr. Morton as saying that "cancer patients are the nicest patients in the world. I truly believe there is a genetic link between kindness and those who are diagnosed with cancer…. After all of these years, I still cannot help but get emotionally involved with my patients and their situations. It is truly rewarding when a patient with a fatal diagnosis is still alive after 5 years but it is crushing when I lose a patient because in essence I am losing a friend."
As reported in the Los Angeles Times, Dr. Morton was born from humble roots — he grew up in a home without electricity or running water. His unlikely rise through medical school began with free enrollment for disadvantaged students.
Dr. Morton is survived by his wife, 5 children, 8 grandchildren, a brother, and a sister. A private funeral will take place on February
-
- February 3, 2015 at 6:18 pm
- 'Practice Changing' MRI Recommendations in Multiple Myeloma
EGFR Mutant Lung Cancer: Lessons From ASPIRATION and IMPRESS
Second-line Oxaliplatin Benefits Pancreatic Cancer Patients
Salivary Gland Cancer: Teamwork Pays Off
Tributes Flow for Sentinel Lymph Node Biopsy Inventor Donald Morton, MD
Kate Johnson
January 23, 2014
Drug & Reference InformationAn icon in surgical oncology passed away this week. Donald Morton, MD, who died from heart failure at the age of 79 years, is credited with changing the direction of cancer treatment by mapping the course of malignant melanoma with his identification of the sentinel lymph node. He also pioneered the development of cancer vaccines.
"It's a huge loss in the cancer world," Anton Bilchik, MD, PhD, told Medscape Medical News. Dr. Bilchik is chief of medicine at the John Wayne Cancer Institute in Santa Monica, California, an institution founded and previously headed by Dr. Morton, who was recently chief of the melanoma program.
Dr. Donald Morton"He was a giant in the field," said Armando E. Giuliano, MD, professor of surgery and associate director of the Samuel Oschin Comprehensive Cancer Center at Cedars-Sinai in Los Angeles, also speaking in an interview.
Both Dr. Bilchik and Dr. Giuliano worked alongside Dr. Morton for many years.
"He was still working and funded by the National Cancer Institute up until the end," said Dr. Giuliano. "He continued to see patients and operate until quite recently. He was loved by his patients."
"He was one of the pioneers of modern cancer research," said Dr. Bilchik. "The [sentinel lymph node] technique that he discovered for melanoma, and which he published in the New England Journal of Medicine, has become the standard of care for the treatment of melanoma around the world, and has saved many people unnecessary lymph node dissections. That concept was then applied to breast cancer, and the first sentinel lymph node procedure for breast cancer was done at the John Wayne Cancer Institute. That, too, became the standard of care for the management of early breast cancer, and now many women around the world have not had to undergo unnecessary lymph node dissections because of that. So his work has really had a tremendous impact on the management of melanoma and breast cancer, and has been applied to improving staging for colon cancer, stomach cancer, and esophageal cancer."
Dr. Morton was also a major contributor to immunotherapy in cancer, said Dr. Giuliano. "His intravesicalar injections of metastatic melanoma to the bladder led the way for BCG treatment of bladder cancer — the first FDA-approved form of cancer immunotherapy. His work on cancer vaccines led to NIH funding for a large prospective randomized trial of an antimelanoma vaccine, which he developed. Dr. Morton was also a pioneer in limb-salvage surgery for soft tissue sarcoma and pulmonary resection for solid tumor metastases."
Teaching and sharing his knowledge was a central preoccupation for Dr. Morton, who, over the course of his career, trained more than 140 surgical fellows.
"There are few people in the world who have trained as many people in cancer as he has," said Dr. Bilchik. "More than 80% of those fellows are now leaders in surgery or cancer research. Many of them are deans, heads of departments, or chairs."
At the same time, Dr. Morton had an extraordinary ability to strike a personal rapport with his patients.
"Many surgeons will operate on a patient, maybe see them postoperatively, and then they'll get followed by their internist or oncologist. But he made a point of following every one of his patients and had a personal relationship with every one of his patients. Many patients would see him who he'd operated on 30 or 40 years ago," said Dr. Bilchik.
An obituary published in the Los Angeles Daily News quotes Dr. Morton as saying that "cancer patients are the nicest patients in the world. I truly believe there is a genetic link between kindness and those who are diagnosed with cancer…. After all of these years, I still cannot help but get emotionally involved with my patients and their situations. It is truly rewarding when a patient with a fatal diagnosis is still alive after 5 years but it is crushing when I lose a patient because in essence I am losing a friend."
As reported in the Los Angeles Times, Dr. Morton was born from humble roots — he grew up in a home without electricity or running water. His unlikely rise through medical school began with free enrollment for disadvantaged students.
Dr. Morton is survived by his wife, 5 children, 8 grandchildren, a brother, and a sister. A private funeral will take place on February
-
- February 3, 2015 at 6:18 pm
- 'Practice Changing' MRI Recommendations in Multiple Myeloma
EGFR Mutant Lung Cancer: Lessons From ASPIRATION and IMPRESS
Second-line Oxaliplatin Benefits Pancreatic Cancer Patients
Salivary Gland Cancer: Teamwork Pays Off
Tributes Flow for Sentinel Lymph Node Biopsy Inventor Donald Morton, MD
Kate Johnson
January 23, 2014
Drug & Reference InformationAn icon in surgical oncology passed away this week. Donald Morton, MD, who died from heart failure at the age of 79 years, is credited with changing the direction of cancer treatment by mapping the course of malignant melanoma with his identification of the sentinel lymph node. He also pioneered the development of cancer vaccines.
"It's a huge loss in the cancer world," Anton Bilchik, MD, PhD, told Medscape Medical News. Dr. Bilchik is chief of medicine at the John Wayne Cancer Institute in Santa Monica, California, an institution founded and previously headed by Dr. Morton, who was recently chief of the melanoma program.
Dr. Donald Morton"He was a giant in the field," said Armando E. Giuliano, MD, professor of surgery and associate director of the Samuel Oschin Comprehensive Cancer Center at Cedars-Sinai in Los Angeles, also speaking in an interview.
Both Dr. Bilchik and Dr. Giuliano worked alongside Dr. Morton for many years.
"He was still working and funded by the National Cancer Institute up until the end," said Dr. Giuliano. "He continued to see patients and operate until quite recently. He was loved by his patients."
"He was one of the pioneers of modern cancer research," said Dr. Bilchik. "The [sentinel lymph node] technique that he discovered for melanoma, and which he published in the New England Journal of Medicine, has become the standard of care for the treatment of melanoma around the world, and has saved many people unnecessary lymph node dissections. That concept was then applied to breast cancer, and the first sentinel lymph node procedure for breast cancer was done at the John Wayne Cancer Institute. That, too, became the standard of care for the management of early breast cancer, and now many women around the world have not had to undergo unnecessary lymph node dissections because of that. So his work has really had a tremendous impact on the management of melanoma and breast cancer, and has been applied to improving staging for colon cancer, stomach cancer, and esophageal cancer."
Dr. Morton was also a major contributor to immunotherapy in cancer, said Dr. Giuliano. "His intravesicalar injections of metastatic melanoma to the bladder led the way for BCG treatment of bladder cancer — the first FDA-approved form of cancer immunotherapy. His work on cancer vaccines led to NIH funding for a large prospective randomized trial of an antimelanoma vaccine, which he developed. Dr. Morton was also a pioneer in limb-salvage surgery for soft tissue sarcoma and pulmonary resection for solid tumor metastases."
Teaching and sharing his knowledge was a central preoccupation for Dr. Morton, who, over the course of his career, trained more than 140 surgical fellows.
"There are few people in the world who have trained as many people in cancer as he has," said Dr. Bilchik. "More than 80% of those fellows are now leaders in surgery or cancer research. Many of them are deans, heads of departments, or chairs."
At the same time, Dr. Morton had an extraordinary ability to strike a personal rapport with his patients.
"Many surgeons will operate on a patient, maybe see them postoperatively, and then they'll get followed by their internist or oncologist. But he made a point of following every one of his patients and had a personal relationship with every one of his patients. Many patients would see him who he'd operated on 30 or 40 years ago," said Dr. Bilchik.
An obituary published in the Los Angeles Daily News quotes Dr. Morton as saying that "cancer patients are the nicest patients in the world. I truly believe there is a genetic link between kindness and those who are diagnosed with cancer…. After all of these years, I still cannot help but get emotionally involved with my patients and their situations. It is truly rewarding when a patient with a fatal diagnosis is still alive after 5 years but it is crushing when I lose a patient because in essence I am losing a friend."
As reported in the Los Angeles Times, Dr. Morton was born from humble roots — he grew up in a home without electricity or running water. His unlikely rise through medical school began with free enrollment for disadvantaged students.
Dr. Morton is survived by his wife, 5 children, 8 grandchildren, a brother, and a sister. A private funeral will take place on February
-
- February 3, 2015 at 2:21 am
Good try, Cooper. But actually, here's the history of sentinel node determination and biopsy:
"The concept of a sentinel node was first described by Gould et al. 1960 in a patient with cancer of the parotid gland and was implemented clinically on a broad scale by Cabanas in penile cancer. The technique of sentinel node radiolocalization was co-founded by James C. Alex, MD, FACS and David N. Krag MD (University of Vermont Medical Center) and they were the first ones to pioneer this technique for the use of cutaneous melanoma, breast cancer, head and neck cancer and Merkel cell carcinoma. Confirmative trials followed soon after. Studies were also conducted at the Moffitt Cancer Center with Charles Cox, MD, Douglas Reintgen, MD and James Norman, MD."
Additionally, I wish that when a trial gains approval and is listed via ClinicalTrials.gov we could KNOW that it would benefit us all. Sadly…that just aint so. Just recently an approved trial combining BRAFi and ipi had to be stopped due to liver toxicity. Various approved trials still use dacarbazine and interferon as the comparative agent…when most ALL the melanoma big dogs have gone on record stating that those are outdated since BRAFi, ipi, and the anti-PD1 products have gained FDA approval. Innumerable vaccine trials have been halted due to their lack of effect. Maybe someday a vaccine will be the cure. That would be fabulous. But, this particular one doesn't have the data to prove that it has any better response rate than the IL2 it is combined with. And that's from the data the trial proponents have published.
Have a good one Coop!! If you or anyone else want to give this one a whirl….go for it. Just wanted folks to be able to make informed choices. c
-
- February 3, 2015 at 2:21 am
Good try, Cooper. But actually, here's the history of sentinel node determination and biopsy:
"The concept of a sentinel node was first described by Gould et al. 1960 in a patient with cancer of the parotid gland and was implemented clinically on a broad scale by Cabanas in penile cancer. The technique of sentinel node radiolocalization was co-founded by James C. Alex, MD, FACS and David N. Krag MD (University of Vermont Medical Center) and they were the first ones to pioneer this technique for the use of cutaneous melanoma, breast cancer, head and neck cancer and Merkel cell carcinoma. Confirmative trials followed soon after. Studies were also conducted at the Moffitt Cancer Center with Charles Cox, MD, Douglas Reintgen, MD and James Norman, MD."
Additionally, I wish that when a trial gains approval and is listed via ClinicalTrials.gov we could KNOW that it would benefit us all. Sadly…that just aint so. Just recently an approved trial combining BRAFi and ipi had to be stopped due to liver toxicity. Various approved trials still use dacarbazine and interferon as the comparative agent…when most ALL the melanoma big dogs have gone on record stating that those are outdated since BRAFi, ipi, and the anti-PD1 products have gained FDA approval. Innumerable vaccine trials have been halted due to their lack of effect. Maybe someday a vaccine will be the cure. That would be fabulous. But, this particular one doesn't have the data to prove that it has any better response rate than the IL2 it is combined with. And that's from the data the trial proponents have published.
Have a good one Coop!! If you or anyone else want to give this one a whirl….go for it. Just wanted folks to be able to make informed choices. c
-
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.