The information on this site is not intended or implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Content within the patient forum is user-generated and has not been reviewed by medical professionals. Other sections of the Melanoma Research Foundation website include information that has been reviewed by medical professionals as appropriate. All medical decisions should be made in consultation with your doctor or other qualified medical professional.

Dr told dad he has Stage IV melanoma on his thigh today!

Forums General Melanoma Community Dr told dad he has Stage IV melanoma on his thigh today!

  • Post
    worried daughter
    Participant

    My dad's Dr told him he has Stage IV melanoma on his thigh. The lab staged it from a biopsy. I was under the impression that you needed a PET Scan or MRI to stage it correctly. Can he be accurately stage from a biopsy? He's scheduled to have it operated on in 2 weeks. He's 81 years old. Please help me to understand if this can be accurately staged this way, if you can. Thank You

    My dad's Dr told him he has Stage IV melanoma on his thigh. The lab staged it from a biopsy. I was under the impression that you needed a PET Scan or MRI to stage it correctly. Can he be accurately stage from a biopsy? He's scheduled to have it operated on in 2 weeks. He's 81 years old. Please help me to understand if this can be accurately staged this way, if you can. Thank You

Viewing 7 reply threads
  • Replies
      Julie in SoCal
      Participant

      Hi Worried Daughter,

      I'm sorry you're go through this, but welcome to this forum.  I've found it a wonderful place with caring folk who know an awful lot about mel.  I trust you will too.

      To answer your question, no, the lab can't stage you're dad at stage iv from an initial biopsy.  You're probably reading the Clark's Level.  That's not the stage.  To be at stage iv, the mel has had to spread.  Hopefully that's not the case for your father.

      For more information on staging you can check out:

      http://www.melanoma.org/learn-more/melanoma-101/staging-melanoma

      Blessings,

      Julie in SoCal

      Julie in SoCal
      Participant

      Hi Worried Daughter,

      I'm sorry you're go through this, but welcome to this forum.  I've found it a wonderful place with caring folk who know an awful lot about mel.  I trust you will too.

      To answer your question, no, the lab can't stage you're dad at stage iv from an initial biopsy.  You're probably reading the Clark's Level.  That's not the stage.  To be at stage iv, the mel has had to spread.  Hopefully that's not the case for your father.

      For more information on staging you can check out:

      http://www.melanoma.org/learn-more/melanoma-101/staging-melanoma

      Blessings,

      Julie in SoCal

        worried daughter
        Participant

        Hi Julie,

        Thank you for your reply. My mom went to the Dr w/him today, and let me add that she is sharp as a tack, and she told me the Dr said, "he has Stage IV melanoma on his thigh and we'll need to operate on it ASAP. 2 weeks from today is the soonest I can book an OR." My mom then told me that he must've seen her heart skip a beat and he then said to her, "Don't worry, he'll live another 35 years." That's what upset me so much because if it is Stage IV melanoma then he's shielding her from the truth & giving her false hope for my dad. I can only hope that my mother heard him incorrectly when she heard Stage IV. Thank God I'm a nurse & she put me on the approved list for info. I will be calling the Dr in the morning. For now, I'm just questioning whether he would even know the stage from a biopsy. I never knew that to be true. He originally went to the Dr for MOHS procedure on 3 areas on his lower leg when the Dr pointed out the area on his thigh that he was more interested in biopsying.

        Hopefully I'll know more tomorrow, but until then I'm powerless.

        Thanks Again,

        WD

         

         

         

         

        worried daughter
        Participant

        Hi Julie,

        Thank you for your reply. My mom went to the Dr w/him today, and let me add that she is sharp as a tack, and she told me the Dr said, "he has Stage IV melanoma on his thigh and we'll need to operate on it ASAP. 2 weeks from today is the soonest I can book an OR." My mom then told me that he must've seen her heart skip a beat and he then said to her, "Don't worry, he'll live another 35 years." That's what upset me so much because if it is Stage IV melanoma then he's shielding her from the truth & giving her false hope for my dad. I can only hope that my mother heard him incorrectly when she heard Stage IV. Thank God I'm a nurse & she put me on the approved list for info. I will be calling the Dr in the morning. For now, I'm just questioning whether he would even know the stage from a biopsy. I never knew that to be true. He originally went to the Dr for MOHS procedure on 3 areas on his lower leg when the Dr pointed out the area on his thigh that he was more interested in biopsying.

        Hopefully I'll know more tomorrow, but until then I'm powerless.

        Thanks Again,

        WD

         

         

         

         

        Janner
        Participant

        PLEASE make sure that a Sentinel Node Biopsy (SNB) will be performed at the time of the tumor removal (WLE – wide local excision).  If the lesion is deeper than 1mm which is very possible with a Clark's Level IV lesion, the SNB must be done PRIOR to the WLE.  They are often done in the same surgical setting, but the SNB has to be done before all the extra tissue is removed with the WLE so the lymphatic drainage paths are not altered.   At this point in time, and without any other biopsies or scans, your father cannot be labeled stage IV, only Clark's Level IV.

        Janner

        Janner
        Participant

        PLEASE make sure that a Sentinel Node Biopsy (SNB) will be performed at the time of the tumor removal (WLE – wide local excision).  If the lesion is deeper than 1mm which is very possible with a Clark's Level IV lesion, the SNB must be done PRIOR to the WLE.  They are often done in the same surgical setting, but the SNB has to be done before all the extra tissue is removed with the WLE so the lymphatic drainage paths are not altered.   At this point in time, and without any other biopsies or scans, your father cannot be labeled stage IV, only Clark's Level IV.

        Janner

      Janner
      Participant

      Pathology never gives a stage.  Staging is done by a doctor based on multiple factors.  If you have a pathology report, it will give you a Breslow Depth.  This is the MOST important factor to look at.  In addition, it might mention Clark's Level.  Clark's Level and stage are often confused in the newly diagnosed, but Clark's Level is what you will see on a pathology report.  In addition, mitosis and ulceration are other important factors.  These are the pieces of information that you need to do an initial staging.  Based on those factors, he may need a sentinel node biopsy and/or scans for additional staging information.  That is why a doctor does staging, not a pathology report. 

      If you have the pathology report, post it here and we can help you.  My father was also diagnosed at age 81 with a stage II lesion.  (Breslow 2.22mm).  He is stage III now, but is also 86 and hanging in there.

      Please post any additional information you have and we'll be happy to help!

      Best wishes,

      Janner

      Janner
      Participant

      Pathology never gives a stage.  Staging is done by a doctor based on multiple factors.  If you have a pathology report, it will give you a Breslow Depth.  This is the MOST important factor to look at.  In addition, it might mention Clark's Level.  Clark's Level and stage are often confused in the newly diagnosed, but Clark's Level is what you will see on a pathology report.  In addition, mitosis and ulceration are other important factors.  These are the pieces of information that you need to do an initial staging.  Based on those factors, he may need a sentinel node biopsy and/or scans for additional staging information.  That is why a doctor does staging, not a pathology report. 

      If you have the pathology report, post it here and we can help you.  My father was also diagnosed at age 81 with a stage II lesion.  (Breslow 2.22mm).  He is stage III now, but is also 86 and hanging in there.

      Please post any additional information you have and we'll be happy to help!

      Best wishes,

      Janner

        worried daughter
        Participant

        Thank you Janner. You've helped me to be armed & dangerous when I speak to the Dr tomorrow!

        worried daughter
        Participant

        Thank you Janner. You've helped me to be armed & dangerous when I speak to the Dr tomorrow!

      JerryfromFauq
      Participant
      What is the dr? Is this a General Practitioner, a local general surgeon, a dermatologist, a general oncologist or a melanoma specialist Oncologist? I strongly recommend a Melanoma Specialist be seen once the initial primary tumor is removed and the pathology report is obtained. Get copies of all records, reports, scans, etc. The specialist will want these as well as to have his own pathologist review the removed tumor. Already having your own copy cn take months off of getting th appointment with the melanoma specialist. Too much is going on in the melanoma field for even a general oncologist to keep up with the trials and resource.
      JerryfromFauq
      Participant
      What is the dr? Is this a General Practitioner, a local general surgeon, a dermatologist, a general oncologist or a melanoma specialist Oncologist? I strongly recommend a Melanoma Specialist be seen once the initial primary tumor is removed and the pathology report is obtained. Get copies of all records, reports, scans, etc. The specialist will want these as well as to have his own pathologist review the removed tumor. Already having your own copy cn take months off of getting th appointment with the melanoma specialist. Too much is going on in the melanoma field for even a general oncologist to keep up with the trials and resource.
        worried daughter
        Participant

        Hi Jerry,

        Dr is one of the top Gen'l Vascular & Minimally Invasive Surgeon in my mom's area. My dad can't come off his Aggranox for surgical procedures, don't ask (can't even be changed to a short acting med ), so this Dr was one of a very few that was tops in his field and would operate under these conditions. I wil take your advice & have her go to a melanoma specialist once the primary tumor is removed and the pathology report is obtained. I have a call into the Dr's office now & hope to receive a call back this afternoon. I'm still hoping it's as simple as my mom misunderstood & heard Clark Level IV rather than Stage IV.

        Thank you for your help.

        WD

        worried daughter
        Participant

        Hi Jerry,

        Dr is one of the top Gen'l Vascular & Minimally Invasive Surgeon in my mom's area. My dad can't come off his Aggranox for surgical procedures, don't ask (can't even be changed to a short acting med ), so this Dr was one of a very few that was tops in his field and would operate under these conditions. I wil take your advice & have her go to a melanoma specialist once the primary tumor is removed and the pathology report is obtained. I have a call into the Dr's office now & hope to receive a call back this afternoon. I'm still hoping it's as simple as my mom misunderstood & heard Clark Level IV rather than Stage IV.

        Thank you for your help.

        WD

        shellebrownies
        Participant

        Dear Worried Daughter,

        It's not possible that the pathology report could have come back as STAGE IV from just a skin biopsy. It's common for people to mistake Stage IV with Clark's Level IV, as has been mentioned already.

        My husband's surgeon could not call his case Stage IV even after removing several cancerous lymph nodes from his armpit, because he would still have had to prove spread to a DISTANT area. It took us another 6 weeks to get the definitive Stage IV diagnosis, and only after taking a sample from a tumor on his liver and having it tested.

        Have your mom (or ask yourself) for a copy of the pathology report if you aren't sure. It will tell you there the answer you seek.

        Very best of luck to you and your family, and yes, a very BIG second to get your father in with a melanoma specialist (not just an oncologist) ASAP.

        Michelle, wife of Don

        shellebrownies
        Participant

        Dear Worried Daughter,

        It's not possible that the pathology report could have come back as STAGE IV from just a skin biopsy. It's common for people to mistake Stage IV with Clark's Level IV, as has been mentioned already.

        My husband's surgeon could not call his case Stage IV even after removing several cancerous lymph nodes from his armpit, because he would still have had to prove spread to a DISTANT area. It took us another 6 weeks to get the definitive Stage IV diagnosis, and only after taking a sample from a tumor on his liver and having it tested.

        Have your mom (or ask yourself) for a copy of the pathology report if you aren't sure. It will tell you there the answer you seek.

        Very best of luck to you and your family, and yes, a very BIG second to get your father in with a melanoma specialist (not just an oncologist) ASAP.

        Michelle, wife of Don

        worried daughter
        Participant

        WOW! You guys/gals are AWESOME! I've received so many great suggestions and all I did was post my concerns on this forum…Which less than 12 hours ago was unknown to me. Please know how much it means to me to know there's support out there and knowledgeable people to help myself & my family through this no matter what the Pathology Report reveals. I've read some of your stories too & I know I'm in great hands here!

        Hugs to all of you!

        WD

        worried daughter
        Participant

        WOW! You guys/gals are AWESOME! I've received so many great suggestions and all I did was post my concerns on this forum…Which less than 12 hours ago was unknown to me. Please know how much it means to me to know there's support out there and knowledgeable people to help myself & my family through this no matter what the Pathology Report reveals. I've read some of your stories too & I know I'm in great hands here!

        Hugs to all of you!

        WD

        Jamietk
        Participant

        You mention that once you have the tumor removed, you will see a melanoma specialist. You really should see one first. The biopsy by another Dr. is fine. But at this point, a WLE is next in line. And if the Breslow depth is more than 1.0, or there is high mitosis, then a SNB is needed too. It is imperative that the SNB be done prior to the WLE. So if a general surgeon does any more removing of tumor or tissue, it could cause inaccuracies in properly determining if the melanoma has spread to the lymph nodes. Once a diagnosis is made through a biopsy, a melanoma specialist is your very next step. Maybe this is the only surgeon so far that has been willing to operate on your dad, and maybe a melanoma specialist/surgeon might have to work with your dad's condition or work with this other surgeon to get the job done. But the melanoma specialist needs to be consulted with before any other surgeries are done.

        Jamietk
        Participant

        You mention that once you have the tumor removed, you will see a melanoma specialist. You really should see one first. The biopsy by another Dr. is fine. But at this point, a WLE is next in line. And if the Breslow depth is more than 1.0, or there is high mitosis, then a SNB is needed too. It is imperative that the SNB be done prior to the WLE. So if a general surgeon does any more removing of tumor or tissue, it could cause inaccuracies in properly determining if the melanoma has spread to the lymph nodes. Once a diagnosis is made through a biopsy, a melanoma specialist is your very next step. Maybe this is the only surgeon so far that has been willing to operate on your dad, and maybe a melanoma specialist/surgeon might have to work with your dad's condition or work with this other surgeon to get the job done. But the melanoma specialist needs to be consulted with before any other surgeries are done.

      worried daughter
      Participant

      So here's the update…thusfar. My dad has a superficial malignant spindle cell carcinoma invasive to Level IV. He's scheduled for a WLE Aug 24th & they'll do a SNB then, too. I was told this is a spreading type of cancer so now my question is, Should the surgery date be moved up??? They said that after the SNB and WLE they will send the biopsy to the Mayo Clinic. If need be the case they will schedule a full body PET Scan depending on the results, and he will then have to meet with Oncology. Please tell me your thoughts on all this,

      Thank you all again for all your help, knowledge & experience.

      WD

      worried daughter
      Participant

      So here's the update…thusfar. My dad has a superficial malignant spindle cell carcinoma invasive to Level IV. He's scheduled for a WLE Aug 24th & they'll do a SNB then, too. I was told this is a spreading type of cancer so now my question is, Should the surgery date be moved up??? They said that after the SNB and WLE they will send the biopsy to the Mayo Clinic. If need be the case they will schedule a full body PET Scan depending on the results, and he will then have to meet with Oncology. Please tell me your thoughts on all this,

      Thank you all again for all your help, knowledge & experience.

      WD

        JerryfromFauq
        Participant

        All melanoms are spreading types.    They spread two ways.  The most common first path is thru the Lymph system.  In this path the first lymph node (called the sentinel lymph node) is the most likely locatioin for melanoma to show up outside the primary tumor.  From the leg the groin is often where the first spread is found. They can also show up "in transit" from the primary location.   They have to be deeper to get to the blood supply to be spread thru the blood.  Once they reach the blood supply they can go anywhere.  If the Sentinel node is cancer free, then it is most likely that the rest of the node group will be to.  If the first node has obvious melanoma then they will likey take additiional nodes to try getting all the ones with cancer and at least a few ones that mel has not yet reached.  A coupl of weeks to wait for the SNB and WLE is standard and not likel;y to be any problem..  My local surgeon waited 3 months.  That is too lonog.for the WLE and he never did a SNB. 

           In my case I wish they had done a PET before removing the hugh groin node I found and the local surgeon wanted to wait 4 additional months after his 3 month delay for the WLE!  My entire left groin lit up like the 4th of July, but less enjoyabl, after his 7 month delay.  Local surgeon was going to delay the removal of the node I FOUND another 2 months!   Glad I got to the University of Virginia when I did.

        JerryfromFauq
        Participant

        All melanoms are spreading types.    They spread two ways.  The most common first path is thru the Lymph system.  In this path the first lymph node (called the sentinel lymph node) is the most likely locatioin for melanoma to show up outside the primary tumor.  From the leg the groin is often where the first spread is found. They can also show up "in transit" from the primary location.   They have to be deeper to get to the blood supply to be spread thru the blood.  Once they reach the blood supply they can go anywhere.  If the Sentinel node is cancer free, then it is most likely that the rest of the node group will be to.  If the first node has obvious melanoma then they will likey take additiional nodes to try getting all the ones with cancer and at least a few ones that mel has not yet reached.  A coupl of weeks to wait for the SNB and WLE is standard and not likel;y to be any problem..  My local surgeon waited 3 months.  That is too lonog.for the WLE and he never did a SNB. 

           In my case I wish they had done a PET before removing the hugh groin node I found and the local surgeon wanted to wait 4 additional months after his 3 month delay for the WLE!  My entire left groin lit up like the 4th of July, but less enjoyabl, after his 7 month delay.  Local surgeon was going to delay the removal of the node I FOUND another 2 months!   Glad I got to the University of Virginia when I did.

Viewing 7 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
About the MRF Patient Forum

The MRF Patient Forum is the oldest and largest online community of people affected by melanoma. It is designed to provide peer support and information to caregivers, patients, family and friends. There is no better place to discuss different parts of your journey with this cancer and find the friends and support resources to make that journey more bearable.

The information on the forum is open and accessible to everyone. To add a new topic or to post a reply, you must be a registered user. Please note that you will be able to post both topics and replies anonymously even though you are logged in. All posts must abide by MRF posting policies.

Popular Topics