The information on this site is not intended or implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Content within the patient forum is user-generated and has not been reviewed by medical professionals. Other sections of the Melanoma Research Foundation website include information that has been reviewed by medical professionals as appropriate. All medical decisions should be made in consultation with your doctor or other qualified medical professional.

Trying to understand?

Forums General Melanoma Community Trying to understand?

  • Post
    jaredmiller16
    Participant

      I am new to the group and I was just diagnosed with Stage 1 (.35) melanoma. I have been trying to do some reseach so I can better understand my diagnosis. I am going to do a profile once I find my dang path report from the move.  My dermatologist kept reiterating to me, "Stage I is a good place to be, you have a 95 % survival rate." Well, when I did my own research, he was right, the five year survival rate is 95%, but then the 10 year survival rate drops to 88%! I think that is scary. So what do I do? Just wait around for it to come back? Do I need to see an oncologist?

      I am new to the group and I was just diagnosed with Stage 1 (.35) melanoma. I have been trying to do some reseach so I can better understand my diagnosis. I am going to do a profile once I find my dang path report from the move.  My dermatologist kept reiterating to me, "Stage I is a good place to be, you have a 95 % survival rate." Well, when I did my own research, he was right, the five year survival rate is 95%, but then the 10 year survival rate drops to 88%! I think that is scary. So what do I do? Just wait around for it to come back? Do I need to see an oncologist?

    Viewing 5 reply threads
    • Replies
        robertgbirch
        Participant

          Hi,

          I had a 0.35 mm melanoma removed last year and so like you am a stage 1er. As your dermatologist said, it is a good place to be, although, after the shock of a cancer diagnosis it may not feel like it is – I know it did not feel like that to me at first. On survival statisticsm  you need to remember that are just a historical study of a particular group and while they can give you an indication of the seriousness of the diagnosis there are many factors involved and so are not necessarily directly applicable to you; for instance our lesions were caught while they were very thin. I would not get too hung up about statistics. I know that is easier said than done.

          Going forward it is important to be vigilant. I had differing advice on how I should follow up; the minimal being an annual dermatological check-up. I’ve been more proactive and see a melanoma specialist every six months (three months in first year) and have had my skin photographed to help identify changes in moles. This works for me but everyone is different and you should do whatever makes you most sense for you.

          Take care,

          Robert

          robertgbirch
          Participant

            Hi,

            I had a 0.35 mm melanoma removed last year and so like you am a stage 1er. As your dermatologist said, it is a good place to be, although, after the shock of a cancer diagnosis it may not feel like it is – I know it did not feel like that to me at first. On survival statisticsm  you need to remember that are just a historical study of a particular group and while they can give you an indication of the seriousness of the diagnosis there are many factors involved and so are not necessarily directly applicable to you; for instance our lesions were caught while they were very thin. I would not get too hung up about statistics. I know that is easier said than done.

            Going forward it is important to be vigilant. I had differing advice on how I should follow up; the minimal being an annual dermatological check-up. I’ve been more proactive and see a melanoma specialist every six months (three months in first year) and have had my skin photographed to help identify changes in moles. This works for me but everyone is different and you should do whatever makes you most sense for you.

            Take care,

            Robert

            robertgbirch
            Participant

              Hi,

              I had a 0.35 mm melanoma removed last year and so like you am a stage 1er. As your dermatologist said, it is a good place to be, although, after the shock of a cancer diagnosis it may not feel like it is – I know it did not feel like that to me at first. On survival statisticsm  you need to remember that are just a historical study of a particular group and while they can give you an indication of the seriousness of the diagnosis there are many factors involved and so are not necessarily directly applicable to you; for instance our lesions were caught while they were very thin. I would not get too hung up about statistics. I know that is easier said than done.

              Going forward it is important to be vigilant. I had differing advice on how I should follow up; the minimal being an annual dermatological check-up. I’ve been more proactive and see a melanoma specialist every six months (three months in first year) and have had my skin photographed to help identify changes in moles. This works for me but everyone is different and you should do whatever makes you most sense for you.

              Take care,

              Robert

              dian in spokane
              Participant

                Statistics project outcomes for groups, not individuals. You are an individual.

                No, you do not need to see an oncologist, and no, you will not just 'wait around for it to come back' There are a lot of proven ways to increase your odds against cancer and heart disease.

                See your family doctor for a yearly physical

                See your dermatologist for regular skin checks. Biopsy suspicious spots if they change or you feel they need to be removed.

                Don't smoke.

                Exercise moderately

                Eat a lot of fresh, colorful vegetables,

                Maintain a healthy weight and lifestyle.

                Avoid sun damage.

                You might also try:

                vitamin D supplementation and turmeric supplements. And if you are into it, there are  a thousand anti cancer diets out there.

                I'd also recommend, laughter, taking up a hobby (if you don't already have one) that includes music, art..some way to express your inner artist and fill your life with joy. Joy kills sorrow. raises endorphins, and empowers the immune system.

                Don't get caught up in those statistics. Then mean nothing really, in terms of you live your life and face your disease. Screw statistics.

                dian

                dian in spokane
                Participant

                  Statistics project outcomes for groups, not individuals. You are an individual.

                  No, you do not need to see an oncologist, and no, you will not just 'wait around for it to come back' There are a lot of proven ways to increase your odds against cancer and heart disease.

                  See your family doctor for a yearly physical

                  See your dermatologist for regular skin checks. Biopsy suspicious spots if they change or you feel they need to be removed.

                  Don't smoke.

                  Exercise moderately

                  Eat a lot of fresh, colorful vegetables,

                  Maintain a healthy weight and lifestyle.

                  Avoid sun damage.

                  You might also try:

                  vitamin D supplementation and turmeric supplements. And if you are into it, there are  a thousand anti cancer diets out there.

                  I'd also recommend, laughter, taking up a hobby (if you don't already have one) that includes music, art..some way to express your inner artist and fill your life with joy. Joy kills sorrow. raises endorphins, and empowers the immune system.

                  Don't get caught up in those statistics. Then mean nothing really, in terms of you live your life and face your disease. Screw statistics.

                  dian

                  dian in spokane
                  Participant

                    Statistics project outcomes for groups, not individuals. You are an individual.

                    No, you do not need to see an oncologist, and no, you will not just 'wait around for it to come back' There are a lot of proven ways to increase your odds against cancer and heart disease.

                    See your family doctor for a yearly physical

                    See your dermatologist for regular skin checks. Biopsy suspicious spots if they change or you feel they need to be removed.

                    Don't smoke.

                    Exercise moderately

                    Eat a lot of fresh, colorful vegetables,

                    Maintain a healthy weight and lifestyle.

                    Avoid sun damage.

                    You might also try:

                    vitamin D supplementation and turmeric supplements. And if you are into it, there are  a thousand anti cancer diets out there.

                    I'd also recommend, laughter, taking up a hobby (if you don't already have one) that includes music, art..some way to express your inner artist and fill your life with joy. Joy kills sorrow. raises endorphins, and empowers the immune system.

                    Don't get caught up in those statistics. Then mean nothing really, in terms of you live your life and face your disease. Screw statistics.

                    dian

                Viewing 5 reply threads
                • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
                About the MRF Patient Forum

                The MRF Patient Forum is the oldest and largest online community of people affected by melanoma. It is designed to provide peer support and information to caregivers, patients, family and friends. There is no better place to discuss different parts of your journey with this cancer and find the friends and support resources to make that journey more bearable.

                The information on the forum is open and accessible to everyone. To add a new topic or to post a reply, you must be a registered user. Please note that you will be able to post both topics and replies anonymously even though you are logged in. All posts must abide by MRF posting policies.

                Popular Topics