The information on this site is not intended or implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Content within the patient forum is user-generated and has not been reviewed by medical professionals. Other sections of the Melanoma Research Foundation website include information that has been reviewed by medical professionals as appropriate. All medical decisions should be made in consultation with your doctor or other qualified medical professional.

“Free fall” between treatments

Forums General Melanoma Community “Free fall” between treatments

  • Post
    rick1981
    Participant

      Hello all,

      There's loads of great posts on this forum about treatments, but I didn't find anything about the period when switching from one treatment to the other.

      My wife is Stage IV, diagnosed in June after several weeks of fever & lesions under her skin appearing, and after many blood tests they ultimately discivered metastatic melanoma after a CT scan. All major symptons disappeared within the first weeks of being on the Dabrafenib/Trametinib combo and her tumors started shrinking on the following CT scans and ultimately she become PET negative on October.

      However, on the next scan in December tumor growth was observed, not only in the main sites (liver, spleen) but now also in her bones in several places. We're now onto immune therapy.

      Since it may takes weeks, if not months, for that therapy to work, we're in a free fall at the moment. Her condition is worsening and we feel new nodes under her skin. The fevers and night sweats are also back.

      So I have two questions:

      – Is there any data on how fast the immune therapy typically needs before it kicks in? I know averages are not very useful here, but maybe there is % after x weeks, % after x+2 treatments, etc information.

      – How did you feel in this period in between treatments? Did you feel worse, did you get additional treatments, were you hospitalized? How did you cope with it mentally.

      For my wife it's very tough as we believed we were on a path to some type of recovery, but now not only is the tumor growth back, so are the symptoms, so it's like starting all over again which is something she had blocked out as a possibility.

      Thanks for sharing your "free fall" experiences, and we hope that the parachute will open soon!

      Thanks, Rick

      (PS. I have posted here several times before but wanted this post to be anynymous for personal reasons, hope you understand)

    Viewing 14 reply threads
    • Replies
        ed williams
        Participant

          Hi Rick it would be helpful to know what kind of Immune therapy your wife is getting. The new PD-1 drugs tend to start working a little faster than Ipi which usuall take up to 3 months to show up on scans. With Pd-1 people are getting responses a lot faster. I had tumor shrinkage by the first set of scans at 12 weeks. In early studies of PD-1 they were able to see reductions by 8 weeks on scans. If you want to do some research on your own there is a really good series on youtube, filmed at the Angeles clinic. Dr. Omid Hamid speaks about new clinical trials that are being looked today. The title to search on youtube is " Future Therapies for Melanoma Education Symposium 2014. Dr. Hamid talks about all the new combination that are being tried today. There are several other videos from different experts in the same series. I hope this was helpful to you and I wish you the best of luck with the treatments. Ed

          ed williams
          Participant

            Hi Rick it would be helpful to know what kind of Immune therapy your wife is getting. The new PD-1 drugs tend to start working a little faster than Ipi which usuall take up to 3 months to show up on scans. With Pd-1 people are getting responses a lot faster. I had tumor shrinkage by the first set of scans at 12 weeks. In early studies of PD-1 they were able to see reductions by 8 weeks on scans. If you want to do some research on your own there is a really good series on youtube, filmed at the Angeles clinic. Dr. Omid Hamid speaks about new clinical trials that are being looked today. The title to search on youtube is " Future Therapies for Melanoma Education Symposium 2014. Dr. Hamid talks about all the new combination that are being tried today. There are several other videos from different experts in the same series. I hope this was helpful to you and I wish you the best of luck with the treatments. Ed

            ed williams
            Participant

              Hi Rick it would be helpful to know what kind of Immune therapy your wife is getting. The new PD-1 drugs tend to start working a little faster than Ipi which usuall take up to 3 months to show up on scans. With Pd-1 people are getting responses a lot faster. I had tumor shrinkage by the first set of scans at 12 weeks. In early studies of PD-1 they were able to see reductions by 8 weeks on scans. If you want to do some research on your own there is a really good series on youtube, filmed at the Angeles clinic. Dr. Omid Hamid speaks about new clinical trials that are being looked today. The title to search on youtube is " Future Therapies for Melanoma Education Symposium 2014. Dr. Hamid talks about all the new combination that are being tried today. There are several other videos from different experts in the same series. I hope this was helpful to you and I wish you the best of luck with the treatments. Ed

              arthurjedi007
              Participant

                Wow. Sorry to hear that. I'm suprised the fevers and sweats are from her disease but like my doc says everyone is different.

                Immunotherapy is slow to work. PD-1 tends to work faster than ipi but it is still at least 9 weeks before good things show up on scans. However she might start feeling better in a couple weeks after the first dose or at least I did. I didn't actually realize it until my parents kept saying how much better I looked.

                For quick results it is usually the braf meds which you already did the combo. There is a phase 1 trial for ERK which is further up the gene chain that might give good results but I can only imagine what the side affects would be. Probably severe.

                For the bone stuff you might want to check out xgeva. It is supposed to strengthen the bones.

                When I switched from the combo which didn't shrink anything for me to Merck's extended access program of pd-1 I was scared. I knew in my gut if it didn't work I wouldn't last long enough for another treatment. That was from April 23 to May 21. I think I was going on sheer will power. I know now my parents were very worried because I didn't have much strength and was rather sickly. In my head though I thought I was in great shape just my body hadn't caught up yet. Also right before April 23 we went to Nashville trying to get into that PD1. That trip really messed up my health. When I got back I had 3 days of major fevers, shakes not able to eat much and stuff. My parents said sometimes I was shaking so hard the heavy recliner was shaking and they had to hold me down. That doc would hardly talk about the pd1 just said it was difficult to get into. Ha. I'm still hear 7 months later thanks to keytruda. One of my former co-workers gave me a book called Jesus Today. The lady who wrote it was going through a lot of medical struggles and it really hit home trying to get me into a good mental state every day I read a couple passages. It's kind of like brainwashing myself into having a positive attitude. When a pain or something hits that's the radiation, or pd1 or xgeva working. Who knows what it really is but that's the attitude I have to have or I would go crazy. I just finished reading it a second time today and will start it again tomorrow. So yeah you just gotta keep fighting and get to that one treatment that works for you. No matter how many meds have failed you. You just gotta keep fighting. My dad says it is hell on earth. But others have beat this for years and years so why not me? Why not you too? Never give up. Never surrender.

                Artie

                 

                arthurjedi007
                Participant

                  Wow. Sorry to hear that. I'm suprised the fevers and sweats are from her disease but like my doc says everyone is different.

                  Immunotherapy is slow to work. PD-1 tends to work faster than ipi but it is still at least 9 weeks before good things show up on scans. However she might start feeling better in a couple weeks after the first dose or at least I did. I didn't actually realize it until my parents kept saying how much better I looked.

                  For quick results it is usually the braf meds which you already did the combo. There is a phase 1 trial for ERK which is further up the gene chain that might give good results but I can only imagine what the side affects would be. Probably severe.

                  For the bone stuff you might want to check out xgeva. It is supposed to strengthen the bones.

                  When I switched from the combo which didn't shrink anything for me to Merck's extended access program of pd-1 I was scared. I knew in my gut if it didn't work I wouldn't last long enough for another treatment. That was from April 23 to May 21. I think I was going on sheer will power. I know now my parents were very worried because I didn't have much strength and was rather sickly. In my head though I thought I was in great shape just my body hadn't caught up yet. Also right before April 23 we went to Nashville trying to get into that PD1. That trip really messed up my health. When I got back I had 3 days of major fevers, shakes not able to eat much and stuff. My parents said sometimes I was shaking so hard the heavy recliner was shaking and they had to hold me down. That doc would hardly talk about the pd1 just said it was difficult to get into. Ha. I'm still hear 7 months later thanks to keytruda. One of my former co-workers gave me a book called Jesus Today. The lady who wrote it was going through a lot of medical struggles and it really hit home trying to get me into a good mental state every day I read a couple passages. It's kind of like brainwashing myself into having a positive attitude. When a pain or something hits that's the radiation, or pd1 or xgeva working. Who knows what it really is but that's the attitude I have to have or I would go crazy. I just finished reading it a second time today and will start it again tomorrow. So yeah you just gotta keep fighting and get to that one treatment that works for you. No matter how many meds have failed you. You just gotta keep fighting. My dad says it is hell on earth. But others have beat this for years and years so why not me? Why not you too? Never give up. Never surrender.

                  Artie

                   

                  arthurjedi007
                  Participant

                    Wow. Sorry to hear that. I'm suprised the fevers and sweats are from her disease but like my doc says everyone is different.

                    Immunotherapy is slow to work. PD-1 tends to work faster than ipi but it is still at least 9 weeks before good things show up on scans. However she might start feeling better in a couple weeks after the first dose or at least I did. I didn't actually realize it until my parents kept saying how much better I looked.

                    For quick results it is usually the braf meds which you already did the combo. There is a phase 1 trial for ERK which is further up the gene chain that might give good results but I can only imagine what the side affects would be. Probably severe.

                    For the bone stuff you might want to check out xgeva. It is supposed to strengthen the bones.

                    When I switched from the combo which didn't shrink anything for me to Merck's extended access program of pd-1 I was scared. I knew in my gut if it didn't work I wouldn't last long enough for another treatment. That was from April 23 to May 21. I think I was going on sheer will power. I know now my parents were very worried because I didn't have much strength and was rather sickly. In my head though I thought I was in great shape just my body hadn't caught up yet. Also right before April 23 we went to Nashville trying to get into that PD1. That trip really messed up my health. When I got back I had 3 days of major fevers, shakes not able to eat much and stuff. My parents said sometimes I was shaking so hard the heavy recliner was shaking and they had to hold me down. That doc would hardly talk about the pd1 just said it was difficult to get into. Ha. I'm still hear 7 months later thanks to keytruda. One of my former co-workers gave me a book called Jesus Today. The lady who wrote it was going through a lot of medical struggles and it really hit home trying to get me into a good mental state every day I read a couple passages. It's kind of like brainwashing myself into having a positive attitude. When a pain or something hits that's the radiation, or pd1 or xgeva working. Who knows what it really is but that's the attitude I have to have or I would go crazy. I just finished reading it a second time today and will start it again tomorrow. So yeah you just gotta keep fighting and get to that one treatment that works for you. No matter how many meds have failed you. You just gotta keep fighting. My dad says it is hell on earth. But others have beat this for years and years so why not me? Why not you too? Never give up. Never surrender.

                    Artie

                     

                    Ginger8888
                    Participant

                      I finished Yervoy on Aug 13th and had my first scans Sept 20th and the spots in my lungs are gone and the one in my neck is half it's size..My dr said that things could look worse before getting better with Yervoy, some swelling might happen also..My 2nd scan is on the 15th..Good luck..I'm stage 3 C

                      Ginger8888
                      Participant

                        I finished Yervoy on Aug 13th and had my first scans Sept 20th and the spots in my lungs are gone and the one in my neck is half it's size..My dr said that things could look worse before getting better with Yervoy, some swelling might happen also..My 2nd scan is on the 15th..Good luck..I'm stage 3 C

                        Ginger8888
                        Participant

                          I finished Yervoy on Aug 13th and had my first scans Sept 20th and the spots in my lungs are gone and the one in my neck is half it's size..My dr said that things could look worse before getting better with Yervoy, some swelling might happen also..My 2nd scan is on the 15th..Good luck..I'm stage 3 C

                            rick1981
                            Participant

                              Good news! How was your scan yesterday? Wishing you all the best!

                              Ginger8888
                              Participant

                                I won't get the results until after Christmas, they are very busy and couldn't get an earlier appt..Will update as soon as i know..

                                Ginger8888
                                Participant

                                  I won't get the results until after Christmas, they are very busy and couldn't get an earlier appt..Will update as soon as i know..

                                  Ginger8888
                                  Participant

                                    I won't get the results until after Christmas, they are very busy and couldn't get an earlier appt..Will update as soon as i know..

                                    rick1981
                                    Participant

                                      Good news! How was your scan yesterday? Wishing you all the best!

                                      rick1981
                                      Participant

                                        Good news! How was your scan yesterday? Wishing you all the best!

                                      Patina
                                      Participant
                                        My Mom was diagnosed at stage IV last year. We found out later that she had brain mets too. She had gamma knife radiation for the mets on 12/9/13 and Yervoy on the 12th. She had a lot of subcutaneous tumors and they started changing and shrinking 3 or 4 days after her first infusion. At 3 weeks there was a big difference and it was more apparent at 6 weeks. In August the said that her response was far above anything they hoped for. Today they feel she is in the group of responders (92%) from the trials @ 5 years are still NED or stable. -She had 25 brain mets treated with no known cognitive issues. Kinda amazing when I write all this down.

                                        She is the exception to the rule, but the doctors feel that the gamma knife treatment really jump started her immune system, which it has been shown to do. Could your wife be a candidate for this?

                                        I am a firm believer in second opinions all along the way. It really helped her more than once.

                                        Hope any of this helps you.

                                        – I made my Mom tske turmeric and had her take drops of Cibdex CBD drops. Not sure if this helped, but it did not hurt and a recent study showed brain met patients who took CBD’s and had gamma knife radiation did better that thoes who had gamma knife alone.

                                        Patina
                                        Participant
                                          My Mom was diagnosed at stage IV last year. We found out later that she had brain mets too. She had gamma knife radiation for the mets on 12/9/13 and Yervoy on the 12th. She had a lot of subcutaneous tumors and they started changing and shrinking 3 or 4 days after her first infusion. At 3 weeks there was a big difference and it was more apparent at 6 weeks. In August the said that her response was far above anything they hoped for. Today they feel she is in the group of responders (92%) from the trials @ 5 years are still NED or stable. -She had 25 brain mets treated with no known cognitive issues. Kinda amazing when I write all this down.

                                          She is the exception to the rule, but the doctors feel that the gamma knife treatment really jump started her immune system, which it has been shown to do. Could your wife be a candidate for this?

                                          I am a firm believer in second opinions all along the way. It really helped her more than once.

                                          Hope any of this helps you.

                                          – I made my Mom tske turmeric and had her take drops of Cibdex CBD drops. Not sure if this helped, but it did not hurt and a recent study showed brain met patients who took CBD’s and had gamma knife radiation did better that thoes who had gamma knife alone.

                                            rick1981
                                            Participant

                                              Thanks for sharing!

                                              I didn't knew there could be positive interaction between gamma knife and immune system treatents, good to know. "Unfortunately" my wife doesn't have brain mets, only then you use gamma knife right?

                                              She's also taking tumeric (in a mix called Zyflamend or Zyflamax) and THC cannabis oil.

                                              Hope your Mom is doing well !

                                              rick1981
                                              Participant

                                                Thanks for sharing!

                                                I didn't knew there could be positive interaction between gamma knife and immune system treatents, good to know. "Unfortunately" my wife doesn't have brain mets, only then you use gamma knife right?

                                                She's also taking tumeric (in a mix called Zyflamend or Zyflamax) and THC cannabis oil.

                                                Hope your Mom is doing well !

                                                rick1981
                                                Participant

                                                  Thanks for sharing!

                                                  I didn't knew there could be positive interaction between gamma knife and immune system treatents, good to know. "Unfortunately" my wife doesn't have brain mets, only then you use gamma knife right?

                                                  She's also taking tumeric (in a mix called Zyflamend or Zyflamax) and THC cannabis oil.

                                                  Hope your Mom is doing well !

                                                Patina
                                                Participant
                                                  My Mom was diagnosed at stage IV last year. We found out later that she had brain mets too. She had gamma knife radiation for the mets on 12/9/13 and Yervoy on the 12th. She had a lot of subcutaneous tumors and they started changing and shrinking 3 or 4 days after her first infusion. At 3 weeks there was a big difference and it was more apparent at 6 weeks. In August the said that her response was far above anything they hoped for. Today they feel she is in the group of responders (92%) from the trials @ 5 years are still NED or stable. -She had 25 brain mets treated with no known cognitive issues. Kinda amazing when I write all this down.

                                                  She is the exception to the rule, but the doctors feel that the gamma knife treatment really jump started her immune system, which it has been shown to do. Could your wife be a candidate for this?

                                                  I am a firm believer in second opinions all along the way. It really helped her more than once.

                                                  Hope any of this helps you.

                                                  – I made my Mom tske turmeric and had her take drops of Cibdex CBD drops. Not sure if this helped, but it did not hurt and a recent study showed brain met patients who took CBD’s and had gamma knife radiation did better that thoes who had gamma knife alone.

                                                  rick1981
                                                  Participant

                                                    Hi all,

                                                    An update on the original post… My wife has a really tough time since the time her BRAF MEK combo stopped working an new tumors appeared in her bones, the first Pembro treatment (with Xgeva) actually seemed to make it worse up to the point she was fully bedridden and could barely eat or drink. Bone pains were also 10/10 without pain killers.

                                                    We then went to hospital on Christmas Eve and got a string of bad news: docter called the situation 'frightening', basic blood values further deteriorated and he mentioned the tumors in her bones (she didn't know yet as the full PET CT results weren't in during our last visit) and also one under her arm pit was visible. We then were told we had to wait for the full blood results before he could give us the second Pembro.

                                                    So we had a pretty quiet and worrisome wait for an hour or so. But then there was good news: LDH values had dropped from 1300 to 650 just above the top of the normal bandwidth! So it seems the Pembro is already working after 1 attempt!

                                                    She then had an extra doses of iron via IV followed by Pembro and Xgeva. 

                                                    We had a pretty quiet Christmas Eve as it had been a long day and trip but the next day she felt pretty good, got dressed and enjoyed a great and long Christmas day with family. The next day she felt again a bit better and the past few days we went out and enjoyed the snow! Quite a chance in a week, maybe some divine intervention ๐Ÿ™‚

                                                    she does still have some bone pains though not nearly as bad as before, gets tired quicky and sometimes nauseous. She also feels some light discomfort in her liver (main tumor location).

                                                    But overall we feel really lucky and although it's very early it seems that the Pd1 treatment is working !! Feeling blessed and hope it continues!

                                                    we are also considering radiation as it may be synergistic but it is many days in a row so it may be tiring due to the travel and the treatment. We'll see.

                                                    will keep you posted and thanks for all the support!

                                                    rick1981
                                                    Participant

                                                      Hi all,

                                                      An update on the original post… My wife has a really tough time since the time her BRAF MEK combo stopped working an new tumors appeared in her bones, the first Pembro treatment (with Xgeva) actually seemed to make it worse up to the point she was fully bedridden and could barely eat or drink. Bone pains were also 10/10 without pain killers.

                                                      We then went to hospital on Christmas Eve and got a string of bad news: docter called the situation 'frightening', basic blood values further deteriorated and he mentioned the tumors in her bones (she didn't know yet as the full PET CT results weren't in during our last visit) and also one under her arm pit was visible. We then were told we had to wait for the full blood results before he could give us the second Pembro.

                                                      So we had a pretty quiet and worrisome wait for an hour or so. But then there was good news: LDH values had dropped from 1300 to 650 just above the top of the normal bandwidth! So it seems the Pembro is already working after 1 attempt!

                                                      She then had an extra doses of iron via IV followed by Pembro and Xgeva. 

                                                      We had a pretty quiet Christmas Eve as it had been a long day and trip but the next day she felt pretty good, got dressed and enjoyed a great and long Christmas day with family. The next day she felt again a bit better and the past few days we went out and enjoyed the snow! Quite a chance in a week, maybe some divine intervention ๐Ÿ™‚

                                                      she does still have some bone pains though not nearly as bad as before, gets tired quicky and sometimes nauseous. She also feels some light discomfort in her liver (main tumor location).

                                                      But overall we feel really lucky and although it's very early it seems that the Pd1 treatment is working !! Feeling blessed and hope it continues!

                                                      we are also considering radiation as it may be synergistic but it is many days in a row so it may be tiring due to the travel and the treatment. We'll see.

                                                      will keep you posted and thanks for all the support!

                                                        DZnDef
                                                        Participant

                                                          I was so concerned when I started reading your update.  I was afraid your story was heading in another direction.  What joy to read of your wife's 180!  Excellent turnaround!  Thank you for sharing the bad that occurred before the good.  It is helpful to know that improvement is possible especially when it appears so bleak.  What a wonderful event to share,  

                                                          Happy New Year (with a fresh dose of New Hope)

                                                          DZnDef
                                                          Participant

                                                            I was so concerned when I started reading your update.  I was afraid your story was heading in another direction.  What joy to read of your wife's 180!  Excellent turnaround!  Thank you for sharing the bad that occurred before the good.  It is helpful to know that improvement is possible especially when it appears so bleak.  What a wonderful event to share,  

                                                            Happy New Year (with a fresh dose of New Hope)

                                                            DZnDef
                                                            Participant

                                                              I was so concerned when I started reading your update.  I was afraid your story was heading in another direction.  What joy to read of your wife's 180!  Excellent turnaround!  Thank you for sharing the bad that occurred before the good.  It is helpful to know that improvement is possible especially when it appears so bleak.  What a wonderful event to share,  

                                                              Happy New Year (with a fresh dose of New Hope)

                                                            rick1981
                                                            Participant

                                                              Hi all,

                                                              An update on the original post… My wife has a really tough time since the time her BRAF MEK combo stopped working an new tumors appeared in her bones, the first Pembro treatment (with Xgeva) actually seemed to make it worse up to the point she was fully bedridden and could barely eat or drink. Bone pains were also 10/10 without pain killers.

                                                              We then went to hospital on Christmas Eve and got a string of bad news: docter called the situation 'frightening', basic blood values further deteriorated and he mentioned the tumors in her bones (she didn't know yet as the full PET CT results weren't in during our last visit) and also one under her arm pit was visible. We then were told we had to wait for the full blood results before he could give us the second Pembro.

                                                              So we had a pretty quiet and worrisome wait for an hour or so. But then there was good news: LDH values had dropped from 1300 to 650 just above the top of the normal bandwidth! So it seems the Pembro is already working after 1 attempt!

                                                              She then had an extra doses of iron via IV followed by Pembro and Xgeva. 

                                                              We had a pretty quiet Christmas Eve as it had been a long day and trip but the next day she felt pretty good, got dressed and enjoyed a great and long Christmas day with family. The next day she felt again a bit better and the past few days we went out and enjoyed the snow! Quite a chance in a week, maybe some divine intervention ๐Ÿ™‚

                                                              she does still have some bone pains though not nearly as bad as before, gets tired quicky and sometimes nauseous. She also feels some light discomfort in her liver (main tumor location).

                                                              But overall we feel really lucky and although it's very early it seems that the Pd1 treatment is working !! Feeling blessed and hope it continues!

                                                              we are also considering radiation as it may be synergistic but it is many days in a row so it may be tiring due to the travel and the treatment. We'll see.

                                                              will keep you posted and thanks for all the support!

                                                          Viewing 14 reply threads
                                                          • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
                                                          About the MRF Patient Forum

                                                          The MRF Patient Forum is the oldest and largest online community of people affected by melanoma. It is designed to provide peer support and information to caregivers, patients, family and friends. There is no better place to discuss different parts of your journey with this cancer and find the friends and support resources to make that journey more bearable.

                                                          The information on the forum is open and accessible to everyone. To add a new topic or to post a reply, you must be a registered user. Please note that you will be able to post both topics and replies anonymously even though you are logged in. All posts must abide byย MRF posting policies.

                                                          Popular Topics