The information on this site is not intended or implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Content within the patient forum is user-generated and has not been reviewed by medical professionals. Other sections of the Melanoma Research Foundation website include information that has been reviewed by medical professionals as appropriate. All medical decisions should be made in consultation with your doctor or other qualified medical professional.

first diagnosis fight plan

Forums General Melanoma Community first diagnosis fight plan

  • Post
    Anya
    Participant

      Just recieved biopsy report – desmoplastic melanoma .85 mm depth . The lesion was on my upper arm–It was sore so I went for my annual full body exam.  Now my dermotologist – who I love- says just excise it and I will be fine.  His partner agrees.  I have had my report and slides sent to NYC where I will be seen next week 11/19/15 by a melanoma specialist.  Any tips for me or questions I should ask? Thanks and God bless all of you

    Viewing 17 reply threads
    • Replies
        mjanssentx
        Participant

          So everybody on this forum will say a couple of things.

          If they come back with a Stage 2 or more results (which we all hope it doesn't)…find a real melanoma specialist (not just an oncologist or dermatologist…but somebody that sees melanoma patients all day long every day of the week.)

          You need to be your own health manager/advocate – do NOT rely on your doctor to manage your health – get educated on the facts – lots of good websites out there to explain the basics and then you can talk to your doctor about options and questions.  

          Don't be afraid to get a second opinion.  I did and probably 75% of the folks on this board have gotten a 2nd or 3rd opinion.

          And if you are Stage 1 – celebrate but be diligent.  Don't live your life in fear (which is easy to do if you are Stage 3 or 4)….but have fun and don't take anything for granted.

          Welcome to this forum….sorry you are here….but lots of people here to help you if you need us.

          Michel

          mjanssentx
          Participant

            So everybody on this forum will say a couple of things.

            If they come back with a Stage 2 or more results (which we all hope it doesn't)…find a real melanoma specialist (not just an oncologist or dermatologist…but somebody that sees melanoma patients all day long every day of the week.)

            You need to be your own health manager/advocate – do NOT rely on your doctor to manage your health – get educated on the facts – lots of good websites out there to explain the basics and then you can talk to your doctor about options and questions.  

            Don't be afraid to get a second opinion.  I did and probably 75% of the folks on this board have gotten a 2nd or 3rd opinion.

            And if you are Stage 1 – celebrate but be diligent.  Don't live your life in fear (which is easy to do if you are Stage 3 or 4)….but have fun and don't take anything for granted.

            Welcome to this forum….sorry you are here….but lots of people here to help you if you need us.

            Michel

            mjanssentx
            Participant

              So everybody on this forum will say a couple of things.

              If they come back with a Stage 2 or more results (which we all hope it doesn't)…find a real melanoma specialist (not just an oncologist or dermatologist…but somebody that sees melanoma patients all day long every day of the week.)

              You need to be your own health manager/advocate – do NOT rely on your doctor to manage your health – get educated on the facts – lots of good websites out there to explain the basics and then you can talk to your doctor about options and questions.  

              Don't be afraid to get a second opinion.  I did and probably 75% of the folks on this board have gotten a 2nd or 3rd opinion.

              And if you are Stage 1 – celebrate but be diligent.  Don't live your life in fear (which is easy to do if you are Stage 3 or 4)….but have fun and don't take anything for granted.

              Welcome to this forum….sorry you are here….but lots of people here to help you if you need us.

              Michel

              Gene_S
              Participant

                Hello,

                Sorry you have to join this group but it has a lot of compassionate and well informed patients and caregivers.

                First I would like to recommend you get a copy of any scans, blood tests, surgeons notes and keep a folder yourself.  Then if you travel to another doctor you don't have to wait for the first doctor to send things on you can take them yourself and they can make copies for their files.

                Judy (loving wife of Gene Stage IV and now NED)

                Gene_S
                Participant

                  Hello,

                  Sorry you have to join this group but it has a lot of compassionate and well informed patients and caregivers.

                  First I would like to recommend you get a copy of any scans, blood tests, surgeons notes and keep a folder yourself.  Then if you travel to another doctor you don't have to wait for the first doctor to send things on you can take them yourself and they can make copies for their files.

                  Judy (loving wife of Gene Stage IV and now NED)

                  Gene_S
                  Participant

                    Hello,

                    Sorry you have to join this group but it has a lot of compassionate and well informed patients and caregivers.

                    First I would like to recommend you get a copy of any scans, blood tests, surgeons notes and keep a folder yourself.  Then if you travel to another doctor you don't have to wait for the first doctor to send things on you can take them yourself and they can make copies for their files.

                    Judy (loving wife of Gene Stage IV and now NED)

                    BrianP
                    Participant

                      Very smart going to the melanoma specialist.  It sounds like that might be from your own undertaking and I applaud you for that.  Will be curious what the specialist says regarding a Sentinel Node Biopsy (SNB).  You may want to google it and see if you can find studies proving or disproving the merits.  If it were me I'd request one.  The standard used to be 1.0 mm or deeper for the procedure but I think some recommend .75 mm or deeper now.

                      Brian

                      BrianP
                      Participant

                        Very smart going to the melanoma specialist.  It sounds like that might be from your own undertaking and I applaud you for that.  Will be curious what the specialist says regarding a Sentinel Node Biopsy (SNB).  You may want to google it and see if you can find studies proving or disproving the merits.  If it were me I'd request one.  The standard used to be 1.0 mm or deeper for the procedure but I think some recommend .75 mm or deeper now.

                        Brian

                        BrianP
                        Participant

                          Very smart going to the melanoma specialist.  It sounds like that might be from your own undertaking and I applaud you for that.  Will be curious what the specialist says regarding a Sentinel Node Biopsy (SNB).  You may want to google it and see if you can find studies proving or disproving the merits.  If it were me I'd request one.  The standard used to be 1.0 mm or deeper for the procedure but I think some recommend .75 mm or deeper now.

                          Brian

                          stars
                          Participant

                            Hi

                            sorry to hear your news, it must be a big shock. The big question for you is: to biopsy lymph nodes or not. In Australia, SLNB is done at 1mm OR if there's something very aggressive about the melanoma. Desmoplastic is one of the more aggressive types, so perhaps this will swing your dr towards a SNLB. The biopsy doesn't have any impact on prognosis, but it does allow more exact staging of the melanoma. Right now, it's stage 1. But if it were found in lymph nodes that would change. This would be the first and foremost question I would ask: SLNB or not.

                            Other than that, reassurance that margins are clear (or are you still waiting for a proper wide level excision? That means about 10 cm scar or slightly less – mine was done under local anaesthetic and took about 45 min maximum). If your SLNB is clear (or if you don't need one) AND your wide level excision is done, you can consider yourself cancer free but very watchful for new or recurring melanoma.

                            The other questions might be about follow up: have you had a full skin exam – if not, get one done. Then: how often do you need to be checked/reviewed, how to do your own (monthly) skin exam and lymph node check if you are really vigilant.

                            This is a great community, use it for information, reassurance and support. It was a Godsend for me!

                            Stars

                            stars
                            Participant

                              Hi

                              sorry to hear your news, it must be a big shock. The big question for you is: to biopsy lymph nodes or not. In Australia, SLNB is done at 1mm OR if there's something very aggressive about the melanoma. Desmoplastic is one of the more aggressive types, so perhaps this will swing your dr towards a SNLB. The biopsy doesn't have any impact on prognosis, but it does allow more exact staging of the melanoma. Right now, it's stage 1. But if it were found in lymph nodes that would change. This would be the first and foremost question I would ask: SLNB or not.

                              Other than that, reassurance that margins are clear (or are you still waiting for a proper wide level excision? That means about 10 cm scar or slightly less – mine was done under local anaesthetic and took about 45 min maximum). If your SLNB is clear (or if you don't need one) AND your wide level excision is done, you can consider yourself cancer free but very watchful for new or recurring melanoma.

                              The other questions might be about follow up: have you had a full skin exam – if not, get one done. Then: how often do you need to be checked/reviewed, how to do your own (monthly) skin exam and lymph node check if you are really vigilant.

                              This is a great community, use it for information, reassurance and support. It was a Godsend for me!

                              Stars

                              stars
                              Participant

                                Hi

                                sorry to hear your news, it must be a big shock. The big question for you is: to biopsy lymph nodes or not. In Australia, SLNB is done at 1mm OR if there's something very aggressive about the melanoma. Desmoplastic is one of the more aggressive types, so perhaps this will swing your dr towards a SNLB. The biopsy doesn't have any impact on prognosis, but it does allow more exact staging of the melanoma. Right now, it's stage 1. But if it were found in lymph nodes that would change. This would be the first and foremost question I would ask: SLNB or not.

                                Other than that, reassurance that margins are clear (or are you still waiting for a proper wide level excision? That means about 10 cm scar or slightly less – mine was done under local anaesthetic and took about 45 min maximum). If your SLNB is clear (or if you don't need one) AND your wide level excision is done, you can consider yourself cancer free but very watchful for new or recurring melanoma.

                                The other questions might be about follow up: have you had a full skin exam – if not, get one done. Then: how often do you need to be checked/reviewed, how to do your own (monthly) skin exam and lymph node check if you are really vigilant.

                                This is a great community, use it for information, reassurance and support. It was a Godsend for me!

                                Stars

                                JoanieM
                                Participant

                                  Hi  there, I also recently got diagnosed – my initial diagnose  was .7 MM (local suburban derm) and then I took that path report to Northwestern memorial hospital  and got the surgical oncologist pathology to review my case for a second opinion and they found my melanoma to be .3 mm – cells were atypical lower but now mel- definitely got a second opinion… I did not opt for an Slnb as I am breast-feeding and it would've interrupted the breast-feeding… Though now I feel nervous I did not – if you have it in you – make sure all avenues are checked to make sure your cancer free! Best of luck to you, try not to be scared, this is just st the beginning. 

                                    Janner
                                    Participant

                                      General rules of thumb for newly diagnosed:  ALWAYS make sure your pathology is read by a dermatopathologist, not just a general pathologist.  Dermatopathologist specialize in skin only, not other tissue types.  Larger institutions will most likely have more than one dp and multiple eyes will verify a diagnosis.  Also, get a copy of your pathology reports for your own records.

                                      Janner
                                      Participant

                                        General rules of thumb for newly diagnosed:  ALWAYS make sure your pathology is read by a dermatopathologist, not just a general pathologist.  Dermatopathologist specialize in skin only, not other tissue types.  Larger institutions will most likely have more than one dp and multiple eyes will verify a diagnosis.  Also, get a copy of your pathology reports for your own records.

                                        Janner
                                        Participant

                                          General rules of thumb for newly diagnosed:  ALWAYS make sure your pathology is read by a dermatopathologist, not just a general pathologist.  Dermatopathologist specialize in skin only, not other tissue types.  Larger institutions will most likely have more than one dp and multiple eyes will verify a diagnosis.  Also, get a copy of your pathology reports for your own records.

                                        JoanieM
                                        Participant

                                          Hi  there, I also recently got diagnosed – my initial diagnose  was .7 MM (local suburban derm) and then I took that path report to Northwestern memorial hospital  and got the surgical oncologist pathology to review my case for a second opinion and they found my melanoma to be .3 mm – cells were atypical lower but now mel- definitely got a second opinion… I did not opt for an Slnb as I am breast-feeding and it would've interrupted the breast-feeding… Though now I feel nervous I did not – if you have it in you – make sure all avenues are checked to make sure your cancer free! Best of luck to you, try not to be scared, this is just st the beginning. 

                                          JoanieM
                                          Participant

                                            Hi  there, I also recently got diagnosed – my initial diagnose  was .7 MM (local suburban derm) and then I took that path report to Northwestern memorial hospital  and got the surgical oncologist pathology to review my case for a second opinion and they found my melanoma to be .3 mm – cells were atypical lower but now mel- definitely got a second opinion… I did not opt for an Slnb as I am breast-feeding and it would've interrupted the breast-feeding… Though now I feel nervous I did not – if you have it in you – make sure all avenues are checked to make sure your cancer free! Best of luck to you, try not to be scared, this is just st the beginning. 

                                            Anya
                                            Participant

                                              am back here January 4,2016.  Had my surgery done in NYC -radical local incision plus sentinal node biopsy.  The sentinal node biopsy was negative. Praise the Lord!  I am one of the lucky ones I say humbly. I am to be monitored every three months by surgeon and dermatologist.  My take away is be vigilant – and tell everyone we know to go for checkups – especially familly members.  My dermatologist says melanoma treatment is astounding — with great advances.  He points to Jimmy Carter. I will keep everyone in my thoughts and prayers.

                                                JoanieM
                                                Participant

                                                  Congrats! So happy for you! 

                                                  JoanieM
                                                  Participant

                                                    Congrats! So happy for you! 

                                                    JoanieM
                                                    Participant

                                                      Congrats! So happy for you! 

                                                    Anya
                                                    Participant

                                                      am back here January 4,2016.  Had my surgery done in NYC -radical local incision plus sentinal node biopsy.  The sentinal node biopsy was negative. Praise the Lord!  I am one of the lucky ones I say humbly. I am to be monitored every three months by surgeon and dermatologist.  My take away is be vigilant – and tell everyone we know to go for checkups – especially familly members.  My dermatologist says melanoma treatment is astounding — with great advances.  He points to Jimmy Carter. I will keep everyone in my thoughts and prayers.

                                                      Anya
                                                      Participant

                                                        am back here January 4,2016.  Had my surgery done in NYC -radical local incision plus sentinal node biopsy.  The sentinal node biopsy was negative. Praise the Lord!  I am one of the lucky ones I say humbly. I am to be monitored every three months by surgeon and dermatologist.  My take away is be vigilant – and tell everyone we know to go for checkups – especially familly members.  My dermatologist says melanoma treatment is astounding — with great advances.  He points to Jimmy Carter. I will keep everyone in my thoughts and prayers.

                                                    Viewing 17 reply threads
                                                    • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
                                                    About the MRF Patient Forum

                                                    The MRF Patient Forum is the oldest and largest online community of people affected by melanoma. It is designed to provide peer support and information to caregivers, patients, family and friends. There is no better place to discuss different parts of your journey with this cancer and find the friends and support resources to make that journey more bearable.

                                                    The information on the forum is open and accessible to everyone. To add a new topic or to post a reply, you must be a registered user. Please note that you will be able to post both topics and replies anonymously even though you are logged in. All posts must abide by MRF posting policies.

                                                    Popular Topics